Skip to content

BER DOE User Facilities Alignment with BioStride

Executive Summary

The U.S. Department of Energy's Biological and Environmental Research (BER) program operates a comprehensive network of structural biology and imaging resources at national user facilities. These resources, spanning synchrotron light sources, neutron facilities, and cryo-electron microscopy centers, generate vast amounts of multi-modal data that require sophisticated data management and integration strategies. BioStride provides an ideal schema framework for harmonizing data across these diverse facilities, enabling cross-facility data integration, workflow tracking, and AI-driven discovery in biological and environmental research.

This document analyzes the alignment between BER DOE user facilities and the BioStride schema, demonstrating how BioStride can serve as a unifying data model for the entire BER structural biology ecosystem.

1. Overview of BER Structural Biology Resources

1.1 Mission and Scope

The BER program supports fundamental research and scientific user facilities advancing DOE missions in: - Scientific discovery and innovation - Energy security and bioeconomy development - Environmental responsibility and climate research - Understanding biological systems from molecules to ecosystems

BER supports 10+ specialized structural biology and imaging resources across 6 major DOE national laboratories, providing free access to the scientific community for non-proprietary research.

1.2 Facility Network

The BER structural biology network encompasses:

  • 6 Synchrotron Light Sources with dedicated BER beamlines
  • 2 Neutron Sources for biological scattering and imaging
  • 3 Cryo-EM Centers with state-of-the-art microscopes
  • Multiple Specialized Imaging Facilities for multi-scale biology

These facilities generate petabytes of data annually across diverse experimental techniques, creating significant challenges for data integration and cross-facility research.

2. Major BER Facilities and Their BioStride Alignment

2.1 Advanced Light Source (ALS) - Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Berkeley Synchrotron Infrared Structural Biology (BSISB)

Capabilities: - Synchrotron radiation-based Fourier transform infrared (SR-FTIR) spectromicroscopy - Time-resolved sFTIR for dynamic studies - Synchrotron Infrared Nano-Spectroscopy (SINS) with ~20 nm resolution - 3D synchrotron FTIR micro-tomography

BioStride Mapping:

FTIRImage:
  is_a: Image2D
  attributes:
    # BSISB-specific metadata
    beamline_id: "ALS-5.4"  # or "ALS-1.4"
    spatial_resolution: 2.0  # micrometers (standard SR-FTIR)
    # or 0.02 for SINS mode (20 nm)

    # Spectral parameters from BSISB
    wavenumber_min: 650   # cm⁻¹
    wavenumber_max: 4000  # cm⁻¹
    spectral_resolution: 4  # cm⁻¹

    # Time-resolved capabilities
    acquisition_mode: "time_resolved"
    time_points: [0, 10, 20, 30, 60, 120]  # seconds

    # 3D tomography extension
    tomography_angles: 180
    reconstruction_method: "filtered_back_projection"

Data Integration Pattern:

class BSISBDataIngester:
    def ingest_bsisb_data(self, raw_data_path):
        # Map BSISB output to BioStride schema
        ftir_image = FTIRImage(
            file_name=raw_data_path,
            beamline_id="ALS-BSISB-5.4",
            wavenumber_range=(650, 4000),
            spatial_resolution=self.extract_pixel_size(raw_data_path),
            molecular_signatures=self.identify_peaks(raw_data_path)
        )

        # Link to experimental context
        experiment = ExperimentRun(
            technique="ftir_spectroscopy",
            instrument_id="ALS-BSISB",
            experimental_conditions=self.parse_metadata(raw_data_path)
        )

        return ftir_image, experiment

National Center for X-ray Tomography (NCXT)

Capabilities: - Soft X-ray tomography (SXT) of intact, hydrated cells - Resolution: 35-50 nm - Sample thickness: up to 15 µm - Correlated cryogenic fluorescence tomography (CFT)

BioStride Mapping:

Image3D:
  is_a: Image
  attributes:
    # NCXT-specific parameters
    beamline_id: "ALS-XM2"
    imaging_mode: "soft_xray_tomography"

    dimensions_x: 1024
    dimensions_y: 1024
    dimensions_z: 180  # number of projections

    voxel_size: 0.035  # micrometers (35 nm)

    # Soft X-ray specific
    photon_energy: 520  # eV (water window)
    dose_per_projection: 1e5  # Gray

    # Correlated imaging
    correlated_fluorescence:
      channel: "GFP"
      colocalization_accuracy: 0.1  # micrometers

Structurally Integrated Biology for Life Sciences (SIBYLS)

Capabilities: - High-throughput SAXS (HT-SAXS) - SEC-SAXS (Size Exclusion Chromatography coupled SAXS) - Mail-in and remote data collection - Integrated crystallography and SAXS

BioStride Mapping:

SAXSInstrument:
  is_a: Instrument
  attributes:
    beamline_id: "ALS-12.3.1"

    # SIBYLS specifications
    q_range_min: 0.01   # Å⁻¹
    q_range_max: 0.60   # Å⁻¹

    # High-throughput capabilities
    sample_changer_capacity: 96
    exposure_time_per_sample: 10  # seconds

    # SEC-SAXS mode
    sec_saxs_enabled: true
    flow_rate: 0.5  # mL/min
    frame_rate: 2   # Hz

2.2 Advanced Photon Source (APS) - Argonne National Laboratory

eBERlight Initiative

Capabilities: - Access to 13 APS beamlines after APS-U upgrade - 500× brighter X-rays than pre-upgrade - Integrated with Advanced Protein Characterization Facility (APCF) - Environmental sample handling laboratories

BioStride Mapping:

Study:
  title: "Environmental Metal Cycling in Wetland Sediments"

  # eBERlight multi-beamline experiment
  instrument_runs:
    - experiment_code: "eBER-2024-001-XRF"
      instrument_id: "APS-2-ID-E"  # Microprobe
      technique: "xrf_imaging"

    - experiment_code: "eBER-2024-001-XRD"
      instrument_id: "APS-11-ID-B"  # High-energy diffraction
      technique: "x_ray_diffraction"

    - experiment_code: "eBER-2024-001-XANES"
      instrument_id: "APS-20-ID"  # X-ray spectroscopy
      technique: "x_ray_spectroscopy"

  # Integration with APCF
  sample_preparations:
    - preparation_type: "protein_expression"
      facility: "APCF"
      protocol: "high_throughput_pipeline"

Cross-Beamline Data Integration:

class eBERlightOrchestrator:
    def coordinate_multi_beamline_experiment(self, study_id):
        # Coordinate data collection across multiple beamlines
        beamline_schedule = self.optimize_beamline_allocation(study_id)

        results = []
        for beamline in beamline_schedule:
            experiment = ExperimentRun(
                experiment_code=f"eBER-{study_id}-{beamline.id}",
                instrument_id=beamline.id,
                technique=beamline.technique,
                experimental_conditions=self.get_conditions(beamline)
            )

            # Real-time data streaming to BioStride
            data = self.collect_data(beamline, experiment)
            validated_data = self.validate_with_biostride(data)
            results.append(validated_data)

        # Integrate multi-modal results
        return self.integrate_results(results)

2.3 National Synchrotron Light Source II (NSLS-II) - Brookhaven National Laboratory

Center for BioMolecular Structure (CBMS)

Capabilities: - Macromolecular crystallography (AMX/FMX beamlines) - Life Science X-ray Scattering (LiX beamline) - X-ray Footprinting (XFP) - Microfocus capabilities for crystals <10 µm

BioStride Mapping:

XRayInstrument:
  is_a: Instrument
  attributes:
    # AMX/FMX beamlines
    beamline_id: "NSLS-II-17-ID-1"  # AMX

    # Micro-crystallography capabilities
    beam_size_min: 1    # micrometers
    beam_size_max: 100  # micrometers

    # Energy range for MAD/SAD
    energy_min: 5    # keV
    energy_max: 18   # keV

    # High-throughput capabilities
    sample_changer_capacity: 384  # UniPuck system
    automated_screening: true

ExperimentRun:
  technique: "x_ray_crystallography"

  # Serial crystallography mode
  collection_mode: "serial"
  number_of_crystals: 1000

  quality_metrics:
    resolution: 1.8  # Angstroms
    completeness: 99.8  # percent
    r_factor: 0.18

Laboratory for BioMolecular Structure (LBMS)

Capabilities: - Two Titan Krios microscopes (300 kV) - Talos Arctica (200 kV) for screening - Sample preparation laboratory - Remote access capabilities

BioStride Mapping:

CryoEMInstrument:
  is_a: Instrument
  attributes:
    facility: "LBMS"
    instrument_code: "LBMS-Krios-1"

    accelerating_voltage: 300  # kV
    cs_corrector: true

    # Detectors
    detector_type: "K3"
    detector_dimensions: "5760x4092"

    # Automation
    autoloader_capacity: 12
    automated_data_collection: true

WorkflowRun:
  workflow_type: "cryoem_spa"

  # LBMS processing pipeline
  software_name: "cryoSPARC"
  processing_parameters:
    motion_correction: "patch_motion"
    ctf_estimation: "patch_ctf"
    particle_picking: "template_matching"

  # Real-time processing
  processing_mode: "on_the_fly"
  streaming_enabled: true

2.4 Oak Ridge National Laboratory - Neutron Facilities

Center for Structural Molecular Biology (CSMB)

Capabilities: - Bio-SANS at High Flux Isotope Reactor (HFIR) - Bio-Deuteration Laboratory at SNS - Complementary SAXS and light scattering - Computational modeling support

BioStride Mapping:

SAXSInstrument:  # Extended for SANS
  is_a: Instrument
  attributes:
    instrument_code: "HFIR-Bio-SANS"
    instrument_type: "neutron_scattering"

    # Neutron-specific parameters
    neutron_wavelength: 6.0  # Angstroms
    wavelength_spread: 0.13  # Δλ/λ

    # Q-range for Bio-SANS
    q_range_min: 0.003  # Å⁻¹
    q_range_max: 0.70   # Å⁻¹

    # Sample environment
    temperature_control_range: "4-80"  # Celsius
    sample_changer_capacity: 18

SamplePreparation:
  preparation_type: "deuteration"

  # Bio-Deuteration Lab parameters
  deuteration_level: 75  # percent
  growth_medium: "D2O-adapted_minimal_media"
  expression_host: "E_coli_BL21"

  # Contrast matching
  d2o_percentage: 42  # for protein contrast matching
  buffer_exchange_cycles: 3

Contrast Variation Analysis:

class SANSContrastVariation:
    def setup_contrast_series(self, sample: BioStrideSample):
        # Generate contrast variation series
        d2o_percentages = [0, 20, 42, 65, 85, 100]

        experiments = []
        for d2o_pct in d2o_percentages:
            exp = ExperimentRun(
                technique="sans",
                instrument_id="HFIR-Bio-SANS",
                sample_id=sample.id,
                experimental_conditions={
                    "d2o_percentage": d2o_pct,
                    "temperature": 25,
                    "contrast_match_point": self.calculate_cmp(sample, d2o_pct)
                }
            )
            experiments.append(exp)

        return experiments

2.5 SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory

Stanford-SLAC Cryo-EM Center (S2C2)

Capabilities: - Four Titan Krios microscopes (300 kV) - Glacios 2 (200 kV) and Tundra (100 kV) - Automated data collection and processing - National service center with free access

BioStride Mapping:

CryoEMInstrument:
  is_a: Instrument
  attributes:
    facility: "S2C2"
    instrument_code: "S2C2-Krios-Alpha"

    # S2C2 specifications
    accelerating_voltage: 300
    energy_filter: "BioQuantum"
    phase_plate: true

    # Automated pipeline
    automated_collection: true
    epu_version: "2.14"

DataFile:
  file_format: "mrc"

  # S2C2 data management
  storage_location: "s2c2_cluster"
  retention_period_days: 60  # on disk
  archive_location: "tape_library"
  archive_retention_months: 24

  # Automated processing results
  motion_corrected: true
  ctf_estimated: true

WorkflowRun:
  # S2C2 on-the-fly processing
  workflow_type: "cryoem_otf"
  software_name: "Relion"

  processing_parameters:
    auto_picking: true
    2d_classification: true
    initial_model: "ab_initio"

Structural Molecular Biology (SMB) Resource

Capabilities: - Biological SAXS beamline (BL4-2) - X-ray crystallography beamlines - X-ray fluorescence imaging - Integrated structural biology approaches

BioStride Mapping:

Study:
  title: "Integrated Structural Analysis of Metalloprotein"

  # Multi-technique at SSRL-SMB
  instrument_runs:
    - technique: "saxs"
      instrument_id: "SSRL-BL4-2"

    - technique: "x_ray_crystallography"
      instrument_id: "SSRL-BL12-2"

    - technique: "xrf_imaging"
      instrument_id: "SSRL-BL2-3"

  # Integrated analysis
  integrated_model:
    crystal_structure: "pdb_8abc"
    saxs_envelope: "sasbdb_entry"
    metal_locations: "xrf_map"
    validation_score: 0.95

2.6 Pacific Northwest National Laboratory

Environmental Molecular Sciences Laboratory (EMSL)

Capabilities: - Cryogenic Transmission Electron Microscopy - Multi-scale imaging platforms - Integration with proteomics and metabolomics - Environmental sample handling

BioStride Mapping:

CryoEMInstrument:
  is_a: Instrument
  attributes:
    facility: "EMSL"
    instrument_code: "EMSL-Titan-Themis"

    # Environmental TEM capabilities
    environmental_holder: true
    temperature_range: "-180 to 1000"  # Celsius
    atmosphere_control: ["vacuum", "N2", "O2", "H2O"]

    # In-situ capabilities
    liquid_cell_tem: true
    gas_reaction_cell: true

Sample:
  sample_type: "environmental"

  # EMSL environmental samples
  sample_origin: "soil_microbiome"
  collection_site: "Hanford_100H"
  gps_coordinates: [46.7, -119.5]

  # Multi-omics integration
  proteomics_data: "EMSL-proteomics-2024-001"
  metabolomics_data: "EMSL-metabolomics-2024-001"

3. Cross-Facility Data Integration Patterns

3.1 Unified Experiment Tracking

BioStride enables seamless tracking of experiments across multiple BER facilities:

Dataset:
  title: "Multi-Facility Study of Plant-Microbe Interactions"
  keywords: ["rhizosphere", "symbiosis", "climate_adaptation"]

  studies:
    - id: "BER-2024-PlantMicrobe-001"

      # Samples shared across facilities
      samples:
        - sample_code: "PM-ROOT-001"
          sample_type: "plant_tissue"

      # Experiments at different facilities
      instrument_runs:
        # NCXT at ALS
        - experiment_code: "NCXT-2024-001"
          instrument_id: "ALS-XM2"
          technique: "soft_xray_tomography"

        # BSISB at ALS
        - experiment_code: "BSISB-2024-001"
          instrument_id: "ALS-5.4"
          technique: "ftir_spectroscopy"

        # eBERlight at APS
        - experiment_code: "eBER-2024-001"
          instrument_id: "APS-2-ID-E"
          technique: "xrf_imaging"

        # Bio-SANS at ORNL
        - experiment_code: "SANS-2024-001"
          instrument_id: "HFIR-Bio-SANS"
          technique: "sans"

        # Cryo-EM at S2C2
        - experiment_code: "S2C2-2024-001"
          instrument_id: "S2C2-Krios-Beta"
          technique: "cryo_em"

3.2 Workflow Orchestration Across Facilities

class BERFacilityOrchestrator:
    def __init__(self):
        self.facilities = {
            'ALS': ALSConnector(),
            'APS': APSConnector(),
            'NSLS-II': NSLSConnector(),
            'ORNL': ORNLConnector(),
            'SLAC': SLACConnector(),
            'EMSL': EMSLConnector()
        }
        self.biostride_validator = BioStrideValidator()

    def orchestrate_multi_facility_study(self, study_plan):
        """
        Coordinate data collection across multiple BER facilities
        """
        study = Study(
            id=study_plan.id,
            title=study_plan.title
        )

        # Schedule experiments based on facility availability
        schedule = self.optimize_facility_schedule(study_plan)

        for facility_exp in schedule:
            # Connect to facility
            facility = self.facilities[facility_exp.facility]

            # Submit experiment
            exp_id = facility.submit_experiment(
                facility_exp.parameters,
                callback=self.handle_data_ready
            )

            # Track in BioStride
            experiment = ExperimentRun(
                experiment_code=exp_id,
                instrument_id=facility_exp.instrument,
                technique=facility_exp.technique
            )
            study.instrument_runs.append(experiment)

        return study

    def handle_data_ready(self, facility, experiment_id, data_path):
        """
        Handle data availability from any facility
        """
        # Ingest into BioStride schema
        data = self.ingest_facility_data(facility, data_path)

        # Validate against schema
        validated = self.biostride_validator.validate(data)

        # Trigger downstream processing
        self.trigger_workflows(validated)

        # Update cross-facility dashboard
        self.update_dashboard(facility, experiment_id, validated)

3.3 Data Harmonization Pipeline

class BERDataHarmonizer:
    def __init__(self):
        self.schema = BioStrideSchema()
        self.converters = self.init_facility_converters()

    def harmonize_facility_data(self, facility_type, raw_data):
        """
        Convert facility-specific formats to BioStride
        """
        converter = self.converters[facility_type]

        # Extract metadata
        metadata = converter.extract_metadata(raw_data)

        # Map to BioStride schema
        biostride_data = self.map_to_schema(facility_type, metadata)

        # Handle facility-specific extensions
        biostride_data = self.add_facility_extensions(
            facility_type, 
            biostride_data, 
            raw_data
        )

        return biostride_data

    def map_to_schema(self, facility_type, metadata):
        """
        Map facility metadata to BioStride schema
        """
        mapping_rules = {
            'ALS': {
                'beamline': 'instrument_id',
                'ring_current': 'experimental_conditions.beam_current',
                'user_id': 'operator_id'
            },
            'APS': {
                'sector': 'instrument_id',
                'bunch_mode': 'experimental_conditions.bunch_pattern',
                'proposal_id': 'study.id'
            },
            'NSLS-II': {
                'beamline': 'instrument_id',
                'scan_id': 'experiment_code',
                'sample_id': 'sample.sample_code'
            }
            # ... more mappings
        }

        return self.apply_mapping(
            metadata, 
            mapping_rules[facility_type]
        )

4. Advanced Integration Capabilities

4.1 Real-Time Data Streaming

BioStride supports real-time data streaming from BER facilities:

class BERDataStreamer:
    def __init__(self):
        self.kafka_client = KafkaClient()
        self.schema_registry = SchemaRegistry()

    async def stream_from_facility(self, facility, experiment_id):
        """
        Stream data in real-time from BER facility
        """
        # Register BioStride schema
        schema_id = self.schema_registry.register(
            f"biostride-{facility}-v1",
            BioStrideSchema.to_avro()
        )

        # Create streaming pipeline
        async for data_chunk in facility.stream_data(experiment_id):
            # Convert to BioStride format
            biostride_chunk = self.convert_chunk(data_chunk)

            # Validate against schema
            validated = self.validate_streaming(biostride_chunk)

            # Publish to Kafka
            await self.kafka_client.produce(
                topic=f"ber.{facility}.data",
                key=experiment_id,
                value=validated,
                schema_id=schema_id
            )

            # Trigger real-time processing
            await self.trigger_streaming_workflows(validated)

4.2 AI-Driven Experiment Optimization

class BERAIOptimizer:
    def __init__(self):
        self.ml_model = ExperimentOptimizationModel()
        self.facility_predictor = FacilityAvailabilityPredictor()

    def optimize_multi_facility_campaign(self, research_goal):
        """
        AI-driven optimization of multi-facility experiments
        """
        # Analyze historical data from BioStride
        historical = self.query_biostride_history(research_goal)

        # Predict optimal facility sequence
        facility_sequence = self.ml_model.predict_sequence(
            goal=research_goal,
            history=historical,
            constraints=self.get_facility_constraints()
        )

        # Generate experiment parameters
        optimized_params = {}
        for facility in facility_sequence:
            params = self.ml_model.optimize_parameters(
                facility=facility,
                goal=research_goal,
                previous_results=optimized_params
            )
            optimized_params[facility] = params

        # Create BioStride study plan
        study = self.create_study_plan(
            facility_sequence,
            optimized_params
        )

        return study

4.3 Federated Learning Across Facilities

class BERFederatedLearning:
    def __init__(self):
        self.facilities = self.init_facility_nodes()
        self.central_model = StructurePredictionModel()

    async def train_federated_model(self, training_config):
        """
        Train ML models across BER facilities without moving data
        """
        # Initialize local models at each facility
        local_models = {}
        for facility in self.facilities:
            local_models[facility] = await facility.init_local_model(
                self.central_model.get_architecture()
            )

        # Federated training rounds
        for round in range(training_config.rounds):
            # Local training at each facility
            for facility in self.facilities:
                # Train on local BioStride data
                local_data = facility.get_biostride_data(
                    training_config.data_filter
                )

                await facility.train_local(
                    local_models[facility],
                    local_data,
                    training_config
                )

            # Aggregate model updates
            model_updates = await self.collect_updates(local_models)
            self.central_model = self.federated_average(model_updates)

            # Distribute updated model
            for facility in self.facilities:
                local_models[facility] = self.central_model.copy()

        return self.central_model

5. Quality Control and Validation

5.1 Cross-Facility Quality Metrics

QualityMetrics:
  description: "Unified quality metrics across BER facilities"
  attributes:
    # Common metrics
    signal_to_noise:
      range: float
      minimum_value: 0

    resolution:
      range: float
      unit: "angstrom_or_nanometer"

    completeness:
      range: float
      minimum_value: 0
      maximum_value: 100

    # Facility-specific extensions
    facility_metrics:
      ALS_BSISB:
        water_vapor_correction: float
        atmospheric_compensation: boolean

      APS_eBERlight:
        beam_stability: float
        flux_variation: float

      ORNL_BioSANS:
        d2o_purity: float
        neutron_flux_stability: float

      S2C2_CryoEM:
        ice_thickness: float
        drift_rate: float

5.2 Automated Validation Pipeline

class BERQualityValidator:
    def __init__(self):
        self.validators = self.init_facility_validators()
        self.ml_validator = MLAnomalyDetector()

    def validate_experiment(self, experiment: ExperimentRun):
        """
        Comprehensive validation for BER facility data
        """
        # Schema validation
        schema_valid = self.validate_schema(experiment)

        # Facility-specific validation
        facility = self.get_facility_from_instrument(
            experiment.instrument_id
        )
        facility_valid = self.validators[facility].validate(experiment)

        # Cross-facility consistency
        if experiment.is_multi_facility():
            consistency = self.check_cross_facility_consistency(
                experiment
            )
        else:
            consistency = True

        # ML-based anomaly detection
        anomalies = self.ml_validator.detect_anomalies(
            experiment,
            reference_set=self.get_reference_data(facility)
        )

        return ValidationReport(
            schema_valid=schema_valid,
            facility_valid=facility_valid,
            consistency=consistency,
            anomalies=anomalies,
            overall_score=self.compute_score(
                schema_valid, 
                facility_valid, 
                consistency, 
                anomalies
            )
        )

6. Implementation Recommendations

6.1 Phased Deployment Strategy

Phase 1: Pilot Implementation (Months 1-6) - Deploy at 2-3 facilities (recommended: ALS, APS, S2C2) - Focus on most common techniques (crystallography, SAXS, cryo-EM) - Establish core schema mappings - Develop facility-specific adapters

Phase 2: Expansion (Months 7-12) - Extend to all BER facilities - Add specialized techniques (neutron scattering, FTIR, XRF) - Implement real-time data streaming - Deploy federated learning infrastructure

Phase 3: Full Integration (Months 13-18) - Complete cross-facility orchestration - Launch AI-driven optimization - Implement automated quality control - Deploy user-facing dashboards

6.2 Technical Architecture

architecture:
  data_layer:
    - facility_adapters: "Custom for each facility"
    - streaming: "Apache Kafka"
    - storage: "S3-compatible object store"
    - lakehouse: "Delta Lake"

  schema_layer:
    - definition: "LinkML (BioStride)"
    - validation: "linkml-validator"
    - registry: "Confluent Schema Registry"
    - versioning: "Git + semantic versioning"

  processing_layer:
    - orchestration: "Apache Airflow"
    - compute: "Ray/Dask clusters"
    - ml_platform: "Kubeflow"
    - monitoring: "Prometheus + Grafana"

  api_layer:
    - graphql: "Facility queries"
    - rest: "Data submission"
    - grpc: "High-performance streaming"
    - websocket: "Real-time updates"

6.3 Governance Structure

class BERDataGovernance:
    def __init__(self):
        self.steering_committee = [
            "BER Program Manager",
            "Facility Directors",
            "User Representatives",
            "Data Scientists"
        ]

        self.working_groups = {
            "schema_evolution": SchemaWorkingGroup(),
            "quality_standards": QualityWorkingGroup(),
            "ai_ethics": AIEthicsWorkingGroup(),
            "user_access": AccessWorkingGroup()
        }

    def propose_schema_change(self, change_request):
        """
        Democratic process for schema evolution
        """
        # Technical review
        technical_review = self.working_groups[
            "schema_evolution"
        ].review(change_request)

        # Impact assessment
        impact = self.assess_facility_impact(change_request)

        # User consultation
        user_feedback = self.collect_user_feedback(change_request)

        # Vote by steering committee
        decision = self.steering_committee.vote(
            change_request,
            technical_review,
            impact,
            user_feedback
        )

        return decision

7. Use Cases and Applications

7.1 Climate Change Research

Study:
  title: "Multi-Scale Analysis of Plant Stress Response to Elevated CO2"

  # Coordinated experiments across facilities
  experiments:
    # Whole plant imaging at ALS
    - facility: "ALS-BSISB"
      technique: "ftir_imaging"
      purpose: "Map metabolic changes in leaves"

    # Cellular structure at NCXT
    - facility: "ALS-NCXT"
      technique: "soft_xray_tomography"
      purpose: "Visualize chloroplast reorganization"

    # Protein structure at S2C2
    - facility: "S2C2"
      technique: "cryo_em"
      purpose: "Determine RuBisCO structural changes"

    # Element distribution at eBERlight
    - facility: "APS-eBERlight"
      technique: "xrf_imaging"
      purpose: "Track nutrient redistribution"

7.2 Bioenergy Research

Study:
  title: "Structural Basis of Lignocellulose Degradation"

  experiments:
    # Enzyme structure at CBMS
    - facility: "NSLS-II-CBMS"
      technique: "x_ray_crystallography"
      purpose: "Cellulase active site structure"

    # Enzyme dynamics at Bio-SANS
    - facility: "ORNL-BioSANS"
      technique: "sans"
      purpose: "Solution dynamics of enzyme complex"

    # Substrate interaction at SSRL
    - facility: "SLAC-SMB"
      technique: "saxs"
      purpose: "Enzyme-substrate complex formation"

7.3 Environmental Remediation

Study:
  title: "Microbial Metal Reduction in Contaminated Sediments"

  experiments:
    # Metal speciation at eBERlight
    - facility: "APS-eBERlight"
      technique: "xanes"
      purpose: "Determine uranium oxidation states"

    # Biofilm structure at EMSL
    - facility: "EMSL"
      technique: "cryo_tem"
      purpose: "Image biofilm architecture"

    # Protein-metal interaction at LBMS
    - facility: "NSLS-II-LBMS"
      technique: "cryo_em"
      purpose: "Structure of metal reductase"

8. Performance Metrics and Benchmarks

8.1 Data Volume Projections

class BERDataMetrics:
    def calculate_annual_data_volume(self):
        """
        Estimate annual data generation across BER facilities
        """
        facility_rates = {
            'ALS': {
                'BSISB': 50,  # TB/year
                'NCXT': 100,   # TB/year
                'SIBYLS': 30   # TB/year
            },
            'APS': {
                'eBERlight': 200  # TB/year (13 beamlines)
            },
            'NSLS-II': {
                'CBMS': 80,    # TB/year
                'LBMS': 500    # TB/year (cryo-EM)
            },
            'ORNL': {
                'BioSANS': 20  # TB/year
            },
            'SLAC': {
                'S2C2': 1000,  # TB/year (4 Krios)
                'SMB': 40      # TB/year
            },
            'EMSL': {
                'CryoTEM': 150 # TB/year
            }
        }

        total = sum(
            sum(beamline_data.values()) 
            for beamline_data in facility_rates.values()
        )

        return total  # ~2.2 PB/year

8.2 Query Performance Targets

performance_targets = {
    'metadata_query': {
        'simple_filter': '< 100ms',
        'complex_join': '< 1s',
        'facility_aggregation': '< 5s'
    },
    'data_retrieval': {
        'single_file': '< 10s',
        'dataset': '< 1min',
        'study': '< 10min'
    },
    'cross_facility_search': {
        'keyword': '< 500ms',
        'structure_similarity': '< 5s',
        'sequence_blast': '< 30s'
    },
    'real_time_streaming': {
        'latency': '< 1s',
        'throughput': '> 1GB/s'
    }
}

9. Challenges and Mitigation Strategies

9.1 Technical Challenges

Challenge: Heterogeneous data formats across facilities Mitigation: - Develop comprehensive adapter library - Use schema-on-read approach for flexibility - Implement automated format detection

Challenge: Real-time processing of high-volume data Mitigation: - Deploy edge computing at facilities - Use streaming architectures (Kafka, Flink) - Implement intelligent data reduction

Challenge: Network bandwidth limitations Mitigation: - Implement data compression and deduplication - Use content delivery networks (CDN) - Deploy regional data caches

9.2 Organizational Challenges

Challenge: Coordination across multiple facilities Mitigation: - Establish clear governance structure - Regular cross-facility meetings - Shared development roadmap

Challenge: User adoption and training Mitigation: - Comprehensive training programs - User-friendly interfaces - Dedicated support team

Challenge: Funding sustainability Mitigation: - Demonstrate clear value proposition - Seek multi-year commitments - Explore cost-sharing models

10. Future Directions

10.1 Emerging Technologies

Quantum Computing Integration - Quantum algorithms for structure prediction - Hybrid classical-quantum workflows - Quantum machine learning for pattern recognition

Digital Twins - Virtual replicas of experiments - Predictive modeling of outcomes - Optimization before physical experiments

Autonomous Experimentation - AI-driven experiment design - Robotic sample handling - Self-optimizing data collection

10.2 Expanded Capabilities

Multi-Modal Data Fusion - Integration with genomics data (JGI) - Proteomics and metabolomics (EMSL) - Environmental sensors (NEON)

Global Collaboration - Integration with European facilities (ESRF, Diamond) - Asia-Pacific partnerships (Spring-8, Australian Synchrotron) - Standardization with wwPDB and EMDB

Advanced Analytics - Graph neural networks for structure prediction - Transformer models for sequence-structure relationships - Reinforcement learning for experiment optimization

Conclusion

The integration of BER DOE User Facilities with the BioStride schema represents a transformative opportunity for biological and environmental research. By providing a unified data model that spans the diverse experimental capabilities of these world-class facilities, BioStride enables:

  1. Seamless Data Integration: Harmonized data from 10+ facilities and dozens of beamlines
  2. Enhanced Scientific Discovery: AI-driven insights from integrated multi-modal data
  3. Improved Efficiency: Reduced time from experiment to insight
  4. Broader Access: Democratized access to complex structural biology data
  5. Reproducible Science: Complete provenance and workflow tracking

The comprehensive alignment between BER facilities and BioStride demonstrates that the schema is well-suited to handle the complexity and scale of modern structural biology research. With proper implementation, this integration will accelerate scientific discovery in critical areas including climate change, bioenergy, and environmental remediation.

The phased deployment strategy, combined with robust governance and continuous evolution of the schema, ensures that BioStride can adapt to emerging technologies and evolving scientific needs while maintaining compatibility with existing facility operations.

As BER facilities continue to upgrade their capabilities—such as the APS-U upgrade providing 500× brighter X-rays—BioStride provides the flexible, extensible framework needed to manage and integrate the resulting exponential growth in data volume and complexity. This positions the BER structural biology community at the forefront of data-driven discovery in the biological and environmental sciences.