Skip to content

Based on the information I've gathered, I'll now review the GO-CAM model "gomodel:5f46c3b700003802" titled "dGMP catabolic process to allantoin (Mouse)".

Review of GO-CAM Model: dGMP catabolic process to allantoin (Mouse)

Model Overview

This model gomodel:5f46c3b700003802 represents the purine degradation pathway, specifically focusing on the conversion of dGMP to allantoin in mouse. The model includes 11 activities (molecular functions) performed by different gene products, with causal associations between them representing the flow of the metabolic pathway.

Pathway Summary

The model depicts a metabolic pathway where: 1. dGMP is processed by nucleotidases (Nt5c, Nt5c1a, and Nt5c2) 2. The resulting deoxyguanosine is processed by purine-nucleoside phosphorylase (Pnp) 3. Guanine is deaminated by guanine deaminase (Gda) 4. Xanthine is oxidized by xanthine oxidase/dehydrogenase (Xdh) 5. Urate is oxidized by urate oxidase (Uox) 6. Unstable intermediates are converted to allantoin by HIU hydrolase (Urah) and OHCU decarboxylase (Urad)

Strengths of the Model

  1. Comprehensive pathway representation: The model captures the complete pathway from dGMP to allantoin, including all relevant intermediate steps.

  2. Appropriate causal associations: The model uses the "provides input for" (RO:0002413) relationship correctly to link the sequential steps of the pathway.

  3. Detailed cellular location information: Each activity is annotated with a cellular location (cytosol or peroxisome) with appropriate evidence.

  4. Well-evidenced: All activities have appropriate evidence codes and literature references.

  5. Input/output molecules: Key chemical compounds like dGMP (CHEBI:16192) and allantoin (CHEBI:15676) are correctly represented.

  6. Consistent with literature: The model is consistent with the literature on purine degradation, as evidenced by the PMID:16462750 paper which details the final steps of urate degradation to allantoin.

Minor Issues and Recommendations

  1. Duplicate causal association: There appears to be a duplicate causal association from Xdh (activity ID: 5f46c3b700003802/5f46c3b700004320) to Uox (activity ID: 5f46c3b700003802/5f46c3b700003818). The same relationship is represented twice with different evidence.

  2. Missing evidence: One causal association from Xdh (activity ID: 5f46c3b700003802/5f46c3b700004320) to Uox has no evidence attached to it.

  3. Missing cellular location evidence: The activity for Dnph1 (ID: 60747c4200000410) has an occurs_in relationship to cytosol (GO:0005829) but lacks evidence for this annotation.

Scientific Accuracy

The model accurately captures the key enzymes and reactions in the purine degradation pathway in mouse. The representation of the terminal pathway from urate to allantoin is particularly well done, including the recently discovered enzymes HIU hydrolase (Urah) and OHCU decarboxylase (Urad) as described in the cited paper (PMID:16462750).

The subcellular localizations are correctly represented, with nucleotidases, purine-nucleoside phosphorylase, and guanine deaminase in the cytosol, while urate oxidase, HIU hydrolase, and OHCU decarboxylase are in peroxisomes, consistent with known biology.

Consistency with GO-CAM Best Practices

The model follows GO-CAM best practices:

  1. Appropriate function annotations: Molecular functions are correctly assigned to gene products.

  2. Proper causal links: The causal relationships between activities use the appropriate relation (RO:0002413 - "provides input for").

  3. Evidence and references: Most assertions are supported by evidence codes and literature references.

  4. Part_of relations: Activities are appropriately marked as being part of the broader biological process (dGMP catabolic process - GO:0046055).

Conclusions and Recommendations

This is a high-quality GO-CAM model that accurately represents the dGMP catabolic pathway leading to allantoin in mouse. The model is scientifically accurate, well-supported by evidence, and follows GO-CAM best practices.

I recommend: 1. Removing the duplicate causal association from Xdh to Uox 2. Adding evidence for the missing causal association 3. Adding evidence for the cellular location of Dnph1

Overall, this model represents a complete metabolic pathway with appropriate gene products, molecular functions, and causal relationships, making it a valuable resource for understanding purine catabolism in mouse.