Skip to content

Now that I have reviewed the GO-CAM model and related information, I'll provide a comprehensive review of GO-CAM model 5fadbcf000002042 "CMP catabolic process (Mouse)".

GO-CAM Model Review: gomodel:5fadbcf000002042 (CMP catabolic process in Mouse)

Model Overview

Title: CMP catabolic process (Mouse)
ID: gomodel:5fadbcf000002042
Taxon: Mouse (NCBITaxon:10090)
Status: Production
Curator: ORCID:0000-0001-7476-6306

This model represents the CMP catabolic process pathway in mouse, showing the enzymatic steps involved in the breakdown of cytidine monophosphate (CMP).

Pathway Structure and Causality

The model presents a clear, linear pathway of CMP catabolism with the following activities connected by causal associations using RO:0002413 (provides input for):

  1. Initial step: Cytidine deaminase (Cda, MGI:MGI:1919519) deaminates CMP to UMP
  2. Branch point: UMP can be processed by either:
  3. Uridine phosphorylase 1 (Upp1, MGI:MGI:1097668)
  4. Uridine phosphorylase 2 (Upp2, MGI:MGI:1923904)
  5. Convergence: Both phosphorylase activities feed into dihydropyrimidine dehydrogenase (Dpyd, MGI:MGI:2139667)
  6. Late steps: The pathway continues through:
  7. Dihydropyrimidinase (Dpys, MGI:MGI:1928679)
  8. Beta-ureidopropionase (Upb1, MGI:MGI:2143535)

The causal relationships accurately represent the flow of metabolites through the catabolic pathway, with each enzyme acting on the product of the previous reaction.

Evidence and Annotations

The model includes appropriate evidence codes and references: - Most activities are supported by ECO:0000314 (direct assay evidence) with appropriate PMID references - Some activities use ECO:0000266 (sequence orthology evidence) with UniProt accessions - All activities are appropriately annotated with molecular functions (GO MF terms) - Most activities are properly annotated as part of the CMP catabolic process (GO:0006248) - Cellular locations are provided where known (cytosol, GO:0005829)

Strengths of the Model

  1. Pathway completeness: The model captures the full CMP catabolic pathway from initial deamination to final breakdown products
  2. Clear causality: The causal relationships clearly show the flow of metabolites through the pathway
  3. Evidence quality: The annotations are supported by appropriate experimental evidence
  4. Subcellular localization: Where known, the cellular locations of activities are included
  5. Branched pathway representation: The model correctly shows the alternative processing paths for UMP

Suggestions for Improvement

  1. Missing terminal process annotation: The final activity (beta-ureidopropionase) lacks a "part_of" relationship to the CMP catabolic process (GO:0006248) that should be added for consistency.

  2. Potential missing input: The initial cytidine deaminase activity has inputs from 5'-nucleotidase (Nt5c3), but the original source of CMP isn't explicitly modeled. Consider adding the source of CMP if known.

  3. Evidence gaps: Some causal associations lack direct evidence annotations. It would strengthen the model to add specific evidence for each causal link where possible.

  4. Cellular location annotations: Some activities are annotated with cellular locations while others aren't. For consistency, consider adding location information for all activities if available.

  5. Unclear reaction products: While the causal relationships show which activities provide input for others, the specific metabolic intermediates aren't explicitly represented. Adding annotations about the specific products might enhance clarity.

Consistency with GO-CAM Guidelines

The model generally follows GO-CAM best practices: - Activities are properly connected with appropriate causal relationships - Gene products are correctly enabled by the appropriate mouse gene identifiers - Evidence is properly documented with appropriate ECO codes and references - The cellular component annotations are correctly used - The "part_of" relationships to the broader biological process are properly included

The model doesn't include any complexes, so the complex annotation guidelines aren't applicable here.

Biological Accuracy

The model accurately represents the CMP catabolic pathway according to published literature: - The enzyme activities match their known molecular functions - The pathway organization reflects the known sequential steps in pyrimidine degradation - The localization information is consistent with what's known about these enzymes

Summary

This GO-CAM model provides a clear, well-structured representation of the CMP catabolic process in mouse. The model successfully captures the enzymatic steps involved and their causal relationships. With a few minor additions and clarifications as suggested above, the model would be even more comprehensive and informative.

The model should be approved for continued production status with consideration of the minor suggested improvements.