Skip to content

Based on my review of the GO-CAM model (gomodel:60418ffa00001019), the relevant literature, and the complex annotation guidelines, I will now provide a comprehensive assessment of this model:

Review of GO-CAM Model: 60418ffa00001019

Model Overview

Model ID: gomodel:60418ffa00001019
Title: "NLRP3 inflammasome in pyroptosis via nlrp3, caspa, caspb etc. (D. rerio)"
Taxon: Danio rerio (zebrafish)
Status: Production

Summary

This model describes the NLRP3 inflammasome in zebrafish (Danio rerio) and its role in pyroptosis. The model captures the activities of key components including NLRP3, ASC (not explicitly shown in the model), caspases (caspa and caspb), and gasdermin proteins that are involved in the pyroptotic inflammatory response pathway.

Strengths

  1. The model is supported by direct experimental evidence from the cited literature (PMID:31852739).
  2. It captures the key molecular components of the NLRP3 inflammasome in zebrafish.
  3. The model includes both the molecular functions and biological processes involved.
  4. The causal relationships between components are represented correctly.

Issues and Recommendations

1. Missing Components

ASC (Adaptor Protein) Representation: - The literature (PMID:31852739) clearly demonstrates that ASC (pycard) is a critical adaptor protein in the NLRP3 inflammasome, connecting NLRP3 to caspases. - While ZFIN:ZDB-GENE-000511-2 (pycard) is mentioned in the objects list, it's not actively represented in the model activities. - Recommendation: Explicitly include pycard (ASC) in the model, showing how it connects NLRP3 to caspases.

2. Inflammasome Complex Representation

Inconsistent Complex Annotation: - The model includes the NLRP3 inflammasome complex (GO:0072559) enabled activities, but doesn't show its members. - According to the "How to annotate complexes in GO-CAM" guidelines, if the subunits carrying specific activities are known (which they are from the literature), they should be represented. - Recommendation: The complex should include NLRP3 and ASC as its members. The complex representation should follow the pattern shown in the guidelines.

3. Causal Relationships

Incomplete Pyroptosis Pathway: - The paper describes a two-step mechanism where: 1) NLRP3-ASC inflammasome activates caspases in an ASC-dependent manner, and 2) NLRP3 directly activates caspase B in an ASC-independent manner to cleave GSDME. - The model shows some but not all of these relationships. - Recommendation: Complete the causal links to show both ASC-dependent and ASC-independent pathways.

4. Molecular Functions

Non-specific Molecular Functions: - Several activities in the model use GO:0003674 (molecular_function) which is a very general term. - For example, NLRP3 (ZFIN:ZDB-GENE-070424-110) has a more specific function described in the paper. - Recommendation: Use more specific molecular function terms where possible, such as: - For NLRP3: inflammasome complex assembly function - For gasdermin: pore-forming activity

5. Evidence Codes

Appropriate Evidence Codes: - The model uses ECO:0000314 (direct assay evidence) and ECO:0000315 (mutant phenotype evidence) appropriately. - This is consistent with the experimental approach in the primary literature.

Biological Accuracy

The model correctly captures the overall mechanism of NLRP3 inflammasome function in zebrafish pyroptosis as described in PMID:31852739, but with some simplifications. The paper describes:

  1. DrNLRP3 can trigger the assembly of a classical inflammasome structure (DrNLRP3-DrASC inflammasome) in an ASC-dependent manner.
  2. This inflammasome activates DrCaspase-A/B by self-cleavage, which then cleaves pro-IL-1β.
  3. DrNLRP3 can also directly recruit and activate DrCaspase-B (without ASC) to cleave GSDME and induce pyroptosis.

The model captures aspects of these relationships but could be more explicit in representing these dual pathways.

Conclusion

This GO-CAM model provides a solid foundation for representing the NLRP3 inflammasome in zebrafish and its role in pyroptosis. The key improvements needed are:

  1. Include ASC (pycard) as an explicit component in the model activities
  2. Better represent the inflammasome complex with its members
  3. Complete the causal relationships to show both ASC-dependent and ASC-independent pathways
  4. Use more specific molecular function terms where appropriate

With these improvements, the model would more accurately capture the complex biology of the NLRP3 inflammasome as described in the literature.