Skip to content

Based on my review, I'll now provide a comprehensive assessment of the GO-CAM model with ID 60418ffa00001200.

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:60418ffa00001200

Overview

The model gomodel:60418ffa00001200 titled "Guanine catabolic process (Mouse)" represents the purine degradation pathway, specifically the uric acid degradation pathway in mouse. This model captures the enzymatic activities and molecular functions involved in converting guanine to allantoin.

Model Structure Analysis

Pathway Described

The model describes the multi-step enzymatic process by which guanine is catabolized to allantoin in mouse (NCBITaxon:10090). The pathway involves multiple enzymes that catalyze sequential reactions:

  1. Guanine deaminase (Gda) - converts guanine to xanthine
  2. Xanthine dehydrogenase/oxidase (Xdh) - oxidizes xanthine to uric acid
  3. Urate oxidase (Uox) - oxidizes uric acid to 5-hydroxyisourate
  4. Hydroxyisourate hydrolase (Urah) - hydrolyzes 5-hydroxyisourate to 2-oxo-4-hydroxy-4-carboxy-5-ureidoimidazoline (OHCU)
  5. OHCU decarboxylase (Urad) - decarboxylates OHCU to allantoin

Causal Associations

The model correctly uses the causal association predicate "RO:0002413" (provides input for) to link the sequential molecular functions, representing the flow of chemical transformations from guanine to allantoin.

Cellular Compartmentalization

The model appropriately captures the cellular compartmentalization of the different enzymatic activities:

  • Guanine deaminase activity occurs in the cytosol (GO:0005829)
  • Xanthine dehydrogenase/oxidase activities occur in both cytosol (GO:0005829) and peroxisome (GO:0005777)
  • The subsequent enzymes in the pathway (Uox, Urah, Urad) function in the peroxisome (GO:0005777)

This compartmentalization is biologically accurate based on the literature evidence.

Evidence Assessment

The model is well-supported by experimental evidence from multiple publications:

  • PMID:1590774 - Establishes the role of xanthine dehydrogenase in mouse liver
  • PMID:16462750 - Provides evidence for the complete uric acid degradation pathway
  • PMID:8064675 - Supports the role of guanine deaminase
  • PMID:31659168 - Recent paper on xanthine oxidoreductase with additional evidence for pathway components

The evidence codes used (ECO:0000314 - direct assay evidence used in manual assertion, ECO:0000266 - sequence orthology evidence) are appropriate for the assertions made.

Protein Functionality Assessment

The model correctly represents the dual functions of Xanthine Dehydrogenase/Oxidase (XDH/XO):

  1. Xanthine dehydrogenase activity (GO:0004854) - uses NAD+ as an electron acceptor
  2. Xanthine oxidase activity (GO:0004855) - uses molecular oxygen as an electron acceptor

This is important as the literature reveals that XDH can be converted to XO by oxidation of sulfhydryl groups or proteolysis, producing reactive oxygen species that have physiological implications.

Biological Accuracy

The pathway representation aligns with current understanding of purine catabolism in mammals. The literature supports that, unlike in humans (where the pathway stops at uric acid due to loss of urate oxidase), mice possess the complete pathway to convert uric acid to allantoin, making it more soluble for excretion.

The model correctly captures the specific role of each enzyme and reflects the two-step process discovered relatively recently (16462750) for converting 5-hydroxyisourate to allantoin via the OHCU intermediate.

Adherence to GO-CAM Best Practices

The model follows GO-CAM best practices by:

  1. Using appropriate causal relationships between activities (RO:0002413 - provides input for)
  2. Properly connecting molecular functions to biological processes (part_of relationships)
  3. Correctly specifying cellular locations (occurs_in relationships)
  4. Including appropriate evidence for each assertion

The placement of molecular functions within the broader biological process (GO:0006147 - guanine catabolic process) is correct, and the directional flow of the pathway is well-represented.

Areas for Potential Improvement

  1. Additional molecular context: The model could potentially include more details about the regulation of these enzymatic activities, especially since xanthine oxidase activity is known to be regulated by environmental factors as described in the literature.

  2. Outputs of final reaction: The model includes CHEBI:15676 (allantoin) as the output of the final step, but could be enhanced by specifying that this is specifically the S-(+)-allantoin form, as mentioned in PMID:16462750.

  3. Biological role context: The model could benefit from connections to broader physiological processes that the guanine catabolic pathway impacts, such as purine homeostasis or responses to oxidative stress.

Conclusion

Overall, this GO-CAM model (gomodel:60418ffa00001200) is a scientifically accurate and well-constructed representation of the guanine catabolic process in mouse. It effectively captures the enzymatic activities, their cellular locations, and the sequential flow of the pathway according to current knowledge. The model includes appropriate evidence for all assertions and follows GO-CAM best practices for representing biochemical pathways.

The representation of this pathway is particularly valuable as it highlights important metabolic differences between mice and humans in purine metabolism, which has implications for studies of diseases like gout and kidney stones, as well as for the use of mice as model organisms for purine metabolism disorders.