Skip to content

Based on my research, I'll now provide a detailed review of GO-CAM model gomodel:60ad85f700000189 (BMP signaling pathway via dpp-tkv/put (D.mel)).

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:60ad85f700000189

Summary

The model gomodel:60ad85f700000189 represents the BMP signaling pathway in Drosophila melanogaster, specifically focusing on the signaling through the Decapentaplegic (Dpp) ligand and its receptors Thickveins (Tkv) and Punt (Put). This is a production-ready model that captures key molecular functions and causal relationships in the BMP signaling pathway.

Overall Assessment

The model accurately represents the core components of the Drosophila BMP signaling pathway and follows the GO-CAM guidelines for pathway representation. The components and their interactions are consistent with current scientific knowledge about BMP signaling in Drosophila.

Strengths

  1. Complete signaling cascade: The model effectively captures the complete BMP signaling pathway from ligand (Dpp) through receptors (Tkv/Put) to downstream effectors (Mad) and transcriptional targets (Medea).

  2. Proper cellular locations: Each activity is correctly associated with its subcellular location - Dpp in extracellular space, receptors at the plasma membrane, and transcription factors in the nucleus or cytosol as appropriate.

  3. Causal relationships: The model correctly represents the causal relationships between pathway components using appropriate relationship predicates (e.g., RO:0002629 "directly positively regulates").

  4. Evidence support: Each activity and relationship is supported by appropriate evidence codes and literature references (e.g., ECO:0000314, ECO:0000315, ECO:0000353).

  5. Biological process context: Activities are properly contextualized within the BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030509).

Areas for Improvement

  1. Regulatory element information: While the model includes transcription factor activities, it doesn't specify the specific target genes or regulatory elements. Adding this information would strengthen the model, particularly for the Mad and Med transcription factors, whose targets are well-studied.

  2. Additional feedback regulators: The model includes Dad, which regulates BMP signaling, but other known feedback regulators in this pathway, such as Brinker (Brk), are not represented.

  3. Ligand processing: The model doesn't capture the processing and maturation of the Dpp ligand, which can influence signaling activity.

  4. Co-receptors: The model doesn't include known co-receptors or modulators of the BMP pathway such as Division abnormally delayed (Dally) and Dally-like protein (Dlp), which regulate Dpp gradient formation.

Detailed Component Analysis

1. Dpp (FB:FBgn0000490)

  • Correctly annotated with receptor ligand activity (GO:0048018)
  • Properly located in extracellular space (GO:0005615)
  • Appropriately linked to the BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030509)
  • Correctly represented as causing activation of the Punt receptor (directly positively regulates)

2. Punt (FB:FBgn0003169)

  • Correctly annotated with BMP receptor activity (GO:0098821)
  • Properly located at plasma membrane (GO:0005886)
  • Appropriately connected to the BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030509)
  • Correctly represented as activating the Tkv receptor

3. Thickveins (FB:FBgn0003716)

  • Correctly annotated with BMP receptor activity (GO:0098821)
  • Properly located at plasma membrane (GO:0005886)
  • Appropriately connected to the BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030509)
  • Correctly represented as activating Mad through phosphorylation

4. Mad (FB:FBgn0011648)

  • Two distinct activities correctly captured:
  • DNA-binding transcription activator activity (GO:0001228) in the nucleus
  • Co-SMAD binding (GO:0070410) in the cytosol
  • Part of BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030509)
  • Correctly represented as activating downstream effectors

5. Medea (FB:FBgn0288966)

  • Correctly annotated with DNA-binding transcription activator activity (GO:0001228)
  • Properly located in nucleus (GO:0005634)
  • Appropriately connected to the BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030509)

6. Dad (FB:FBgn0020493)

  • Correctly annotated with BMP receptor binding (GO:0070700)
  • Properly connected to negative regulation of BMP signaling pathway (GO:0030514)
  • Correctly represented as inhibiting Mad activity

Causal Relationships

The model accurately represents the following causal relationships: - Dpp → Punt (RO:0002629, directly positively regulates) - Punt → Tkv (RO:0002629, directly positively regulates) - Tkv → Mad (RO:0002629, directly positively regulates) - Mad → Medea (RO:0002629, directly positively regulates) - Dad → Mad (RO:0002630, directly negatively regulates)

These relationships correctly capture the canonical BMP signaling cascade in Drosophila.

Consistency with Literature

The model is consistent with the current scientific understanding of BMP signaling in Drosophila as described in the literature. The references cited (e.g., PMID:20010841, PMID:18588885, PMID:28130362) support the model components and relationships.

Recommendations for Improvement

  1. Add gene targets: Include specific gene targets regulated by the Mad-Medea complex, such as known BMP target genes (e.g., brinker, optomotor-blind, spalt).

  2. Include additional regulators: Add other known regulators of the pathway such as Brinker, which antagonizes BMP signaling.

  3. Represent Dpp gradient formation: Consider including components that regulate the Dpp morphogen gradient, such as Dally and Dlp.

  4. Ligand processing: Include the processing and maturation of Dpp, including the role of Furin proteases.

  5. Alternative receptors: Consider adding the Saxophone (Sax) receptor, which can function alongside Tkv in certain contexts.

  6. Gbb ligand: Consider including the Glass bottom boat (Gbb) ligand, which often functions with Dpp, potentially as a heterodimer.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model gomodel:60ad85f700000189 provides a well-constructed representation of the core BMP signaling pathway in Drosophila melanogaster. It accurately captures the key molecular functions, cellular locations, and causal relationships in this pathway. With the suggested improvements, the model could provide an even more comprehensive representation of this important developmental signaling pathway.