Skip to content

Based on my review of GO-CAM model 60ad85f700000259 "activin receptor signaling pathway via Actbeta-babo/put (D.mel)" and the relevant documentation, I'll now provide a comprehensive assessment of the model.

GO-CAM Model Review: activin receptor signaling pathway via Actbeta-babo/put (D.mel)

Model Overview

This GO-CAM model (https://bioregistry.io/go.model:60ad85f700000259) represents the activin receptor signaling pathway in Drosophila melanogaster, specifically focusing on the signaling cascade from Activin-beta (Actbeta) through the type I receptor Baboon (babo) and the type II receptor Punt (put).

Model Structure and Components

The model depicts the following key components:

  1. Ligand: Actbeta (FB:FBgn0024913) with cytokine activity (GO:0005125) in extracellular space (GO:0005615)
  2. Type I receptor: Baboon (FB:FBgn0011300) with activin receptor activity (GO:0017002) on plasma membrane (GO:0005886)
  3. Type II receptor: Punt (FB:FBgn0003169) with activin receptor activity (GO:0017002)
  4. Signal transducer: Smox (FB:FBgn0025800) with co-SMAD binding (GO:0070410) and DNA-binding transcription factor activity (GO:0000981) in nucleus (GO:0005634)
  5. Transcription factor: Medea (FB:FBgn0288966) with DNA-binding transcription activator activity (GO:0001228) in nucleus (GO:0005634)

Signaling Flow

The model correctly captures the canonical activin signaling pathway with appropriate causal associations:

  1. Actbeta (ligand) directly positively regulates (RO:0002629) Punt (type II receptor)
  2. Punt directly positively regulates (RO:0002629) Baboon (type I receptor)
  3. Baboon directly positively regulates (RO:0002629) Smox (R-Smad)
  4. Smox directly positively regulates (RO:0002629) both:
  5. Itself as a DNA-binding transcription factor (GO:0000981)
  6. Medea (co-Smad) as a DNA-binding transcription activator (GO:0001228)

All components are appropriately labeled as part of the activin receptor signaling pathway (GO:0032924).

Strengths

  1. Accurate receptor representation: The model correctly depicts the type I (Baboon) and type II (Punt) receptors with appropriate molecular functions and cellular locations.

  2. Proper signaling cascade: The causal flow correctly shows the progression from ligand to receptor to downstream effectors with appropriate relationships.

  3. Cellular compartmentalization: Components are properly assigned to their cellular locations (extracellular space, plasma membrane, nucleus).

  4. Evidence support: The model contains appropriate evidence codes and literature references, including key papers on Drosophila activin signaling (PMID:10320478, PMID:28130362).

Compliance with GO-CAM Best Practices

According to the "Signaling receptor activity annotation guidelines" document, the model follows best practices for representing protein ligand-activated signaling receptors:

  1. Ligand representation: Actbeta correctly enables cytokine activity (a child of receptor ligand activity) and is located in extracellular space.

  2. Receptor representation: Both receptors have appropriate activin receptor activities and the type I receptor (Baboon) is correctly located in the plasma membrane.

  3. Causal relations: The model correctly uses "directly positively regulates" (RO:0002629) between components of the signaling pathway, as specified in the guidelines.

  4. Context annotation: All activities are properly contextualized with appropriate GO cellular component terms and are part of the activin receptor signaling pathway.

Minor Issues

  1. Missing biological process for Medea: While all other components are labeled as part of the activin receptor signaling pathway (GO:0032924), Medea's DNA-binding transcription activator activity is labeled as part of this process, but the process isn't explicitly connected to the component itself. This is a minor annotation issue.

  2. Potential missing receptor target genes: The model could be expanded to include specific target genes that are activated by the Smox-Medea complex, as mentioned in the reviewed literature (specifically from PMID:28130362 which mentions Atg8a as a direct target).

Recommendations for Improvement

  1. Add biological process annotation for Medea: Ensure that Medea is explicitly linked to the activin receptor signaling pathway (GO:0032924) process.

  2. Consider adding target genes: Include specific target genes regulated by the Smox-Medea complex to make the model more comprehensive.

  3. Consider adding receptor complex formation: While the current representation is valid, explicitly modeling the formation of the receptor heterotetramer (two type I and two type II receptors) could provide additional clarity about the signaling mechanism.

  4. Consider adding phosphorylation states: Adding information about the phosphorylation of Smox by Baboon would provide additional mechanistic detail.

Conclusion

Overall, this GO-CAM model accurately represents the activin receptor signaling pathway in Drosophila melanogaster and follows GO-CAM best practices for signaling pathway representation. The model captures the key components, their appropriate molecular functions, cellular locations, and the causal relationships between them. With some minor enhancements as suggested above, the model could provide even more comprehensive representation of this important signaling pathway.