Skip to content

Now I'll review the model based on the information gathered. Let me analyze whether it follows best practices and if the biological content is consistent with literature.

GO-CAM Model Review: dTMP Biosynthetic Process (gomodel:60e7989d00000165)

Summary

This GO-CAM model represents the dTMP (deoxythymidine monophosphate) biosynthetic process in mouse (Mus musculus). The model describes a pathway essential for DNA synthesis, showing how various enzymes function together to produce dTMP, a critical nucleotide precursor.

Model Structure and Connectivity

The model contains 9 activities connected by causal relationships using the "provides input for" (RO:0002413) predicate, creating a coherent pathway flow. The model shows:

  1. The ribonucleoside-diphosphate reductase complex (GO:0005971) initiates the pathway by converting UDP to dUDP
  2. Multiple nucleoside diphosphate kinase activities (Nme1, Nme2, Nme3) convert dUDP to dUTP
  3. dUTP diphosphatase (Dut) converts dUTP to dUMP
  4. Thymidylate synthase (Tyms) converts dUMP to dTMP
  5. Two parallel paths involving serine hydroxymethyltransferase activities (Shmt1, Shmt2) and dihydrofolate reductase (Dhfr) support the thymidylate synthase reaction

Strengths of the Model

  1. Compartmentalization accuracy: The model correctly places the activities in the nucleus, which is consistent with the literature (PMID:19513116) that demonstrates nuclear de novo thymidylate biosynthesis.

  2. Species specificity: The model properly uses mouse-specific gene products (MGI identifiers) and reflects mouse biology.

  3. Evidence quality: The model incorporates appropriate evidence codes and literature references supporting each assertion.

  4. Pathway completeness: The model captures all key steps in the dTMP biosynthetic pathway.

  5. Redundancy representation: The model correctly represents the functional redundancy between Shmt1 and Shmt2 in nuclear folate metabolism, as demonstrated in the literature.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Complex representation: The ribonucleoside-diphosphate reductase complex (GO:0005971) is represented without specifying its members. According to the GO-CAM best practices for annotating complexes, if the subunits carrying specific activities are known, they should be individually represented.

  2. Missing SUMO modification details: The literature (PMID:19513116) emphasizes that SHMT1, DHFR, and TYMS undergo SUMOylation for nuclear localization during S and G2/M phases. This post-translational modification, which is important for nuclear localization, is not captured in the model.

  3. Missing cell cycle context: The literature indicates that the nuclear localization of these enzymes is cell cycle-dependent (occurring during S and G2/M phases), which is not represented in the model.

  4. Molecular details: Some intermediate molecular steps in folate metabolism could be more explicitly modeled to show how one-carbon units from serine are utilized for thymidylate biosynthesis.

Consistency with Literature

The model is well-supported by the literature evidence provided:

  • PMID:19513116 provides strong experimental evidence for nuclear thymidylate biosynthesis and the roles of SHMT1 and SHMT2 in this process
  • The molecular functions assigned to each protein are consistent with their known activities
  • The subcellular localization of activities in the nucleus is correct and experimentally validated

The model correctly captures the finding that both SHMT1 and SHMT2 (specifically SHMT2alpha) contribute to nuclear de novo thymidylate biosynthesis, with SHMT2alpha providing redundancy that may account for the viability of Shmt1-/- mice.

Recommendation

This model is scientifically accurate and follows most GO-CAM best practices. I recommend accepting the model with minor suggested improvements:

  1. Consider specifying the members of the ribonucleoside-diphosphate reductase complex (GO:0005971) if known
  2. Add context about the cell cycle-dependence of this pathway
  3. Consider representing the SUMOylation of SHMT1, DHFR, and TYMS as this post-translational modification is critical for their nuclear localization

Overall, this is a high-quality GO-CAM model that effectively represents the current understanding of the dTMP biosynthetic process in mice.