Skip to content

Now I'll review the GO-CAM model with ID 61283a3000000217 based on GO-CAM best practices and scientific literature.

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:61283a3000000217

Model Overview

This model titled "Cobalamin metabolic process 1, adenosylation of cobalamin (Mouse)" represents the pathway of cobalamin (vitamin B12) metabolism in mouse, specifically focusing on the adenosylation of cobalamin. The model is sourced from Reactome pathways R-HSA-196741 and R-HSA-3149560.

Overall Structure and Composition

The model consists of 6 activities representing proteins involved in cobalamin processing:

  1. MMACHC (MGI:MGI:1914346) - Functions in two distinct roles:
  2. Oxidoreductase activity (GO:0016491)

  3. Cyanocobalamin reductase activity (GO:0033787)

  4. MMADHC (MGI:MGI:1923786) - Molecular carrier activity (GO:0140104)

  5. MMAB (MGI:MGI:1924947) - Corrinoid adenosyltransferase activity (GO:0008817)

  6. MMAA (MGI:MGI:1923805) - Molecular carrier activity (GO:0140104)

  7. MMUT (MGI:MGI:97239) - Methylmalonyl-CoA mutase activity (GO:0004494)

These activities are connected in a pathway that represents the processing of cobalamin to adenosylcobalamin and its subsequent use.

Pathway Flow Analysis

The model represents a linear process flow:

  1. MMACHC (oxidoreductase) → MMADHC
  2. MMACHC (cyanocobalamin reductase) → MMADHC
  3. MMADHC → MMAB (positively regulates)
  4. MMAB → MMAA
  5. MMAA (with input from cobamamide) → MMUT

This pathway correctly represents the known steps in cobalamin metabolism where: - MMACHC processes incoming cobalamin forms (removes the upper axial ligand) - MMADHC works with MMACHC to direct cobalamin toward adenosylation - MMAB functions as adenosyltransferase to create adenosylcobalamin - MMAA acts as a molecular carrier/chaperone - MMUT uses adenosylcobalamin as a cofactor

Cellular Localization Accuracy

The cellular localizations are accurate: - MMACHC is correctly annotated to occur in the cytosol (GO:0005829) - MMAB, MMAA, and MMUT are correctly annotated to the mitochondrial matrix (GO:0005759)

Evidence and Literature Support

The model uses appropriate evidence codes: - Orthology evidence (ECO:0000266) from human studies is appropriately used - Direct assay evidence (ECO:0000314) is used for MMUT - Curator inferences (ECO:0000305) are properly applied

The evidence is supported by PMIDs that match the functions described, including key papers on MMACHC (PMID:21697092, PMID:22642810) that describe its dual roles.

Strengths of the Model

  1. Pathway Completeness: The model captures the key enzymes involved in the adenosylation pathway of cobalamin.

  2. Accurate Molecular Functions: The molecular functions are correctly assigned to each protein, especially the dual functions of MMACHC.

  3. Proper Use of Molecular Carrier Activity: The model correctly uses GO:0140104 (molecular carrier activity) for proteins that function as carriers/chaperones (MMADHC and MMAA).

  4. Appropriate Causal Relations: The causal relationships (RO:0002413 "provides input for" and RO:0002304 "causally upstream of, positive effect") are used correctly.

  5. Chemical Inputs/Outputs: The model correctly includes cobamamide (CHEBI:18408) as an input for MMAA.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Missing Small Molecules: While cobamamide is included, some intermediate forms of cobalamin (such as cob(I)alamin) are not explicitly represented in the pathway.

  2. Evidence Gaps: Some causal associations lack evidence codes, which would strengthen the model.

  3. Molecular Context Completeness: For MMACHC, glutathione is an important cofactor for its dealkylation activity but is not represented in the model.

  4. Process Context: While individual activities are annotated to "cobalamin metabolic process" (GO:0009235), the specific subprocesses (e.g., "adenosylcobalamin biosynthetic process") could be more precisely annotated.

Conformance to GO-CAM Best Practices

The model generally follows GO-CAM best practices:

  1. Molecular Carrier Activity: The model correctly uses GO:0140104 as specified in the "Molecular carrier activity" guidelines document.

  2. Activity Flow: The pathway is represented as a linear flow with appropriate causal relations.

  3. Cellular Context: The activities are appropriately annotated with cellular locations.

  4. Evidence: The model uses appropriate evidence codes and references.

Biological Accuracy

The biological process represented is accurate according to current understanding of cobalamin metabolism:

  1. MMACHC functions as both an oxidoreductase and a cyanocobalamin reductase, processing various forms of cobalamin.

  2. MMADHC interacts with MMACHC and directs processed cobalamin toward adenosylation pathways.

  3. MMAB functions as a corrinoid adenosyltransferase, converting cob(I)alamin to adenosylcobalamin.

  4. MMAA acts as a carrier/chaperone for adenosylcobalamin.

  5. MMUT uses adenosylcobalamin as a cofactor for methylmalonyl-CoA mutase activity.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model (gomodel:61283a3000000217) accurately represents the adenosylation pathway of cobalamin metabolism in mouse. It captures the key proteins, their molecular functions, cellular locations, and the pathway flow according to current scientific knowledge. The model is well-evidenced and follows GO-CAM best practices.

Minor improvements could be made by including additional small molecule intermediates and more specific process annotations, but overall, this model provides a clear and accurate representation of the biological pathway.