Skip to content

Now that I've gathered all the necessary information, I'll review the GO-CAM model:

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:617b481400000672

Model Overview

Title: KAT5 chromatin localization (Human) Taxon: Human (NCBITaxon:9606) Status: Production

Summary

This model describes the chromatin localization of KAT5 (also known as Tip60) and its activities in the context of positive regulation of transcription and DNA damage response. The model shows how KAT5 is regulated through phosphorylation by CDK9 and VRK1, and how KAT5's subsequent activities affect transcription and DNA damage response.

Model Strengths

  1. Accurate representation of KAT5 molecular activities:
  2. The model correctly represents KAT5's chromatin binding activity (GO:0003682)

  3. The histone acetyltransferase activity (GO:0004402) and H4K16 acetyltransferase activity (GO:0046972) are properly represented

  4. Proper subcellular localization:

  5. The model correctly places KAT5 activities in chromatin (GO:0000785)

  6. Biological context:

  7. The model appropriately connects KAT5's activities to positive regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II (GO:0045944) and DNA damage response (GO:0006974)

  8. Causal relationships:

  9. The model shows the correct regulatory relationships where:

    • CDK9's protein serine/threonine kinase activity leads to KAT5 chromatin binding
    • VRK1's protein serine/threonine kinase activity leads to KAT5 chromatin binding
    • KAT5's chromatin binding leads to histone acetyltransferase activity

  10. Evidence basis:

  11. The model uses appropriate evidence codes (ECO:0000314 - direct assay evidence used in manual assertion)
  12. References to primary literature (PMID:29335245 and PMID:33076429) are provided

Areas for Improvement

  1. Specificity of phosphorylation sites:

  2. The model does not specify which specific serine residues are phosphorylated. Based on the literature (PMID:29335245), CDK9 phosphorylates KAT5 at serine 90 (S90), which is critical for its association with chromatin. This detail could be added to the model.

  3. Temporal sequence of activities:

  4. While the causal relationships are correctly represented, the temporal sequence is not entirely clear. The literature indicates that S90 phosphorylation is required for subsequent S86 phosphorylation by GSK3, which together enhance KAT5's HAT activity. This sequential relationship could be made more explicit.

  5. Missing GSK3 regulation:

  6. According to PMID:29335245, GSK3 phosphorylates S86 of KAT5 using S90 phosphorylation as a priming site. This important regulatory component is missing from the model.

  7. Model completeness:

  8. The model focuses primarily on the regulation of KAT5 localization but could be expanded to include:

    • H2AX acetylation by KAT5, which is important for NBS1 recruitment to DNA damage sites
    • ATM acetylation by KAT5, which is required for ATM activation in DNA damage response

  9. Complex representation:

  10. According to the GO-CAM guidelines for complexes, if KAT5 is part of the NuA4 histone acetyltransferase complex during these activities, this could be represented. The model currently treats KAT5 as an individual protein rather than as part of its known complex.

Recommendations

  1. Add specific phosphorylation sites:
  2. Specify that CDK9 phosphorylates KAT5 at S90

  3. Specify that VRK1 phosphorylates KAT5 (though the exact site may not be specified in the literature)

  4. Include GSK3 regulation:

  5. Add GSK3's role in phosphorylating KAT5 at S86, which depends on prior S90 phosphorylation

  6. Expand downstream events:

  7. Include KAT5's role in acetylating H2AX at K5

  8. Include KAT5's role in acetylating ATM at K3016

  9. Clarify complex participation:

  10. If appropriate, indicate KAT5's participation in the NuA4 histone acetyltransferase complex when performing its acetyltransferase activities

  11. Add additional disease relevance:

  12. Consider adding information about KAT5's role in cancer resistance to DNA-damaging agents, which is mentioned in the literature

Conclusion

Overall, this is a well-constructed GO-CAM model that accurately represents the key activities of KAT5 in chromatin and its regulation by kinases. The model effectively captures how KAT5's activities contribute to transcriptional regulation and DNA damage response. With the suggested improvements, particularly regarding the specificity of phosphorylation sites and the inclusion of GSK3 regulation, the model would provide an even more complete representation of the biological mechanisms involved in KAT5 function.