Skip to content

Based on all the information gathered, I'll now review the GO-CAM model with ID 622aace900001389.

Review of GO-CAM Model 622aace900001389 "Pentose-phosphate shunt 2 (Mouse)"

Overview

This GO-CAM model (ID 622aace900001389) represents the pentose-phosphate shunt (or pentose phosphate pathway) in mouse. The model focuses on three key enzymatic activities and their connections within this pathway:

  1. Ribokinase activity (RBKS/MGI:MGI:1918586)
  2. Transketolase activity (TKT/MGI:MGI:105992)
  3. Transaldolase activity (TALDO1/MGI:MGI:1274789)

Model Structure and Flow

The model represents the following sequence of activities: - Ribokinase (RBKS) phosphorylates D-ribose → provides input for Transketolase (TKT) - TKT converts sugars in the pathway → provides input for Transaldolase (TALDO1) - TALDO1 carries out transaldolase activity → generates more sugar intermediates - Another instance of TKT activity produces final outputs of the pathway

All activities occur in the cytosol (GO:0005829) and are part of the pentose-phosphate shunt biological process (GO:0006098).

Evaluation of Evidence

The model is well-supported by experimental evidence: - All molecular functions are backed by direct assay evidence (ECO:0000314) - The final outputs of the pathway (CHEBI:57634 - β-D-fructofuranose 6-phosphate and CHEBI:59776 - D-glyceraldehyde 3-phosphate) are properly annotated

Quality Assessment

Strengths: 1. The model correctly represents the flow of activities in the non-oxidative branch of the pentose phosphate pathway 2. Each activity is properly annotated with appropriate molecular functions and cellular locations 3. All activities are connected using the appropriate causal relationship (RO:0002413 "provides input for") 4. The evidence is from primary literature with appropriate citations (PMID:5360673, PMID:13405914) 5. The outputs of the pathway are properly defined chemical entities

Issues for improvement: 1. Missing input molecules: While the model shows D-ribose (CHEBI:47013) as input for the first reaction, it does not explicitly show all inputs for each reaction step. For completeness, it would be beneficial to include all substrate molecules.

  1. Limited scope: The model only covers part of the pentose phosphate pathway. It focuses on the non-oxidative branch (starting with ribose) but doesn't include the oxidative branch starting with glucose-6-phosphate. A more comprehensive model would include both branches.

  2. Missing ATP as cofactor: The ribokinase activity requires ATP as a cofactor, which is not explicitly represented in the model.

  3. Incomplete reaction details: While the final products are shown for one transketolase reaction, similar details for intermediate reactions would strengthen the model's completeness.

Biological Coherence

The model accurately represents the biological process as described in the literature. The pentose phosphate pathway includes both oxidative and non-oxidative branches, and this model focuses primarily on the non-oxidative branch, starting with ribokinase activity on D-ribose. The sequence of activities (ribokinase → transketolase → transaldolase → transketolase) is consistent with our understanding of this pathway.

According to the literature on the pentose phosphate pathway, transketolase and transaldolase are indeed the key enzymes of the non-oxidative branch that interconvert various sugar phosphates. The model correctly represents this, with transketolase shown to have specific output molecules in the final step.

GO-CAM Best Practices Compliance

The model follows GO-CAM best practices: 1. Activities are connected appropriately using the "provides input for" (RO:0002413) causal relation 2. Each activity is properly associated with a gene product 3. Each activity occurs in the appropriate cellular compartment (cytosol) 4. All activities are part of the correct biological process (pentose-phosphate shunt) 5. Evidence is provided for assertions with appropriate ECO codes

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model 622aace900001389 presents a clear and accurate representation of part of the pentose phosphate pathway in mouse, focusing on the non-oxidative branch. The model is well-structured and properly annotated with appropriate molecular functions, cellular locations, and causal relationships between activities.

For future enhancement, the model could be expanded to include: 1. The oxidative branch of the pentose phosphate pathway 2. More detailed representation of all inputs and outputs for each reaction 3. Explicit representation of cofactors like ATP for ribokinase

Overall, this is a high-quality model that provides valuable information about the pentose phosphate pathway in mouse and follows GO-CAM best practices.