Skip to content

Now that I have gathered the necessary information, I'll provide a comprehensive review of GO-CAM model 627d95ee00000024 (IL12-mediated signaling pathway - Human).

Review of GO-CAM Model gomodel:627d95ee00000024

Model Information

  • ID: gomodel:627d95ee00000024
  • Title: IL12-mediated signaling pathway (Human)
  • Taxon: Human (NCBITaxon:9606)
  • Status: Production

Overview of the Model

This model represents the IL-12-mediated signaling pathway in humans, which is important for immune function. IL-12 is a heterodimeric cytokine comprised of IL12A (p35) and IL12B (p40) subunits that plays a critical role in regulating T-cell and natural killer cell responses.

Model Structure and Flow

The model depicts the following key elements of the IL-12 signaling pathway:

  1. IL-12 cytokine (IL12A/IL12B) binds to its receptor complex (IL12RB1/IL12RB2)
  2. Receptor binding activates associated tyrosine kinases (TYK2, JAK2)
  3. Activated kinases lead to STAT4 activation
  4. STAT4 translocates to the nucleus and acts as a transcription factor

Detailed Evaluation

Pathway Components and Connectivity

The model correctly represents the major components of the IL-12 signaling pathway:

  1. IL-12 Cytokine (represented by two subunits):
  2. IL12A (UniProtKB:P29459) with protein binding and cytokine activity

  3. IL12B (UniProtKB:P29460) with cytokine activity

  4. IL-12 Receptor Complex:

  5. IL12RB1 (UniProtKB:P42701) with interleukin-12 receptor activity

  6. IL12RB2 (UniProtKB:Q99665) with coreceptor activity

  7. Tyrosine Kinases:

  8. TYK2 (UniProtKB:P29597) with protein tyrosine kinase activity

  9. JAK2 (UniProtKB:O60674) with protein tyrosine kinase activity

  10. Transcription Factor:

  11. STAT4 (UniProtKB:Q14765) with DNA-binding transcription factor activity

Causal Relationships

The causal associations in the model use appropriate predicates for representing signaling flow:

  • IL12A and IL12B proteins directly positively regulate (RO:0002629) the receptor activities
  • IL12RB1 and IL12RB2 directly positively regulate (RO:0002629) the tyrosine kinase activities
  • JAK2 directly positively regulates (RO:0002629) STAT4 activity

Subcellular Localization

The model correctly localizes the activities to appropriate cellular compartments:

  • IL12A/IL12B proteins in extracellular space (GO:0005615)
  • IL12RB1/IL12RB2 at the plasma membrane (GO:0005886)
  • TYK2 at the cytoplasmic side of plasma membrane (GO:0009898)
  • JAK2 at the cytoplasmic side of plasma membrane (extrinsic component, GO:0031234)
  • STAT4 in the nucleus (GO:0005634)

Evidence and References

The model uses appropriate evidence codes and references from the literature: - Most associations are supported by experimental evidence (ECO:0000314 - direct assay evidence) - Primary references include PMID:7528775, PMID:10899108, PMID:7584494, and PMID:8943050 - The model has proper provenance with contributor identification

Quality Control Issues

1. Missing Causal Association

One of the causal associations has missing evidence: 

{"type":"CausalAssociation","evidence":[],"predicate":"RO:0002629","downstream_activity":"gomodel:627d95ee00000024/62900b6400000186"}

This appears to be a redundant causal association between IL12A (P29459) and IL12RB1 (P42701) that lacks evidence. The same causal relationship is already represented with proper evidence from PMID:7584494, so this appears to be a duplication error.

2. Incorrect Reference Format

One reference appears to be incorrectly formatted: 

"evidence":[{"term":"ECO:0000314","reference":" 7638186","provenances":[{"contributor":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7646-0052","date":"2022-05-30"}]}]

The PMID is formatted with a leading space instead of the proper "PMID:" prefix.

3. Duplicate Causal Associations

The model contains duplicate causal associations: 

{
"type":"CausalAssociation","evidence":[{"term":"ECO:0000314","reference":"PMID:7584494","provenances":[{"contributor":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7646-0052","date":"2022-05-30"}]}],"predicate":"RO:0002629","downstream_activity":"gomodel:627d95ee00000024/62900b6400000186"
},
{
"type":"CausalAssociation","evidence":[],"predicate":"RO:0002629","downstream_activity":"gomodel:627d95ee00000024/62900b6400000186"
},
{
"type":"CausalAssociation","evidence":[{"term":"ECO:0000314","reference":"PMID:7584494","provenances":[{"contributor":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7646-0052","date":"2022-05-30"}]},{"term":"ECO:0000314","reference":"PMID:7584494","provenances":[{"contributor":"https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7646-0052","date":"2022-05-30"}]}],"predicate":"RO:0002629","downstream_activity":"gomodel:627d95ee00000024/62900b6400000186"}
This creates unnecessary redundancy in the model.

Biological Accuracy Assessment

The model accurately represents the biological understanding of the IL-12 signaling pathway as described in the literature:

  1. The heterodimeric nature of IL-12 (IL12A/IL12B) is correctly represented
  2. The receptor complex (IL12RB1/IL12RB2) and its binding to IL-12 is properly modeled
  3. The recruitment and activation of JAK2 and TYK2 kinases is accurately depicted
  4. The activation of STAT4 and its nuclear translocation for transcriptional activity is correct

This is consistent with the information from PMID:7528775, which describes how IL-12 activates JAK2 and TYK2 for signal transduction, and PMID:8943050, which characterizes the functional IL-12 receptor complex composed of IL12RB1 and IL12RB2.

Consistency with GO-CAM Best Practices

The model follows the GO-CAM guidelines for representing complexes as described in "How to annotate complexes in GO-CAM":

  1. The IL-12 cytokine is represented as separate subunits (IL12A and IL12B) with their respective activities, as appropriate when individual subunit activities are known
  2. The receptor components (IL12RB1 and IL12RB2) are similarly represented as separate entities with their specific activities
  3. The causality relationships between components maintain proper biological sequence

Recommendations for Improvement

  1. Remove redundant causal associations: The duplicate and empty evidence causal associations should be removed

  2. Fix reference format: The reference to PMID:7638186 should be properly formatted with the "PMID:" prefix

  3. Consider adding phosphorylation details: The model could be enhanced by explicitly representing the phosphorylation events that occur during signaling, such as the phosphorylation of STAT4 by JAK2

  4. Add downstream gene expression effects: The model could be extended to include some of the downstream genes regulated by STAT4, particularly those involved in T-helper cell differentiation

  5. Potentially include negative regulation components: IL-12 signaling is regulated by various mechanisms, and including negative regulators could provide a more complete picture of the pathway

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model gomodel:627d95ee00000024 is an accurate and well-structured representation of the IL-12 signaling pathway in humans. It correctly captures the key components, their subcellular localization, and the causal relationships between them. The model is well-supported by experimental evidence from the literature and follows GO-CAM best practices for representing signaling pathways.

Despite a few minor issues with redundant associations and a formatting error in one reference, the model provides a clear and biologically accurate depiction of IL-12 signaling. With the suggested improvements, it could serve as an excellent reference model for immunology research and teaching purposes.