Skip to content

Based on my review of the GO-CAM model (gomodel:627d95ee00002159) and relevant guidelines, I'll provide a comprehensive assessment.

GO-CAM Review for Model: gomodel:627d95ee00002159

Model Overview

Title: "Xenopus trio, and cdh11 in development and neural cell migration."
Taxonomic context: NCBITaxon:8355 (Xenopus)
Status: Production
Contributor: ORCID:0000-0003-1074-8103 (date: 2022-05-26)

Model Structure and Content

This model represents a pathway in Xenopus describing the role of Trio (a Rho guanine nucleotide exchange factor) and Cadherin-11 (cdh11) in neural cell migration, particularly in cranial neural crest cells. The model includes several molecular function activities with causal relationships between them:

  1. Trio (Xenbase:XB-GENE-6252075) enables guanyl-nucleotide exchange factor activity (GO:0005085)
  2. Trio (Xenbase:XB-GENE-6252075) enables protein binding activity (GO:0005515)
  3. Rac1 (Xenbase:XB-GENE-489012) enables GTPase activity (GO:0003924)
  4. Dvl1 (Xenbase:XB-GENE-865024) enables small GTPase binding (GO:0031267)
  5. Cadherin-11 (Xenbase:XB-GENE-17340654) enables molecular function (GO:0003674)

The model represents direct positive regulation (RO:0002629) relationships from Trio's GEF activity to Rac1's GTPase activity, and from Dvl1's small GTPase binding to Rac1's GTPase activity. Cadherin-11 activity is shown to have a necessary and specific dependency on (RO:0002411) Trio's molecular function activity.

Strengths

  1. Evidence basis: All activities and causal relationships are supported by experimental evidence (ECO:0000314 - direct assay evidence; ECO:0006051 - morpholino experiment evidence) from the referenced publication PMID:32366678.

  2. Functional consistency: The molecular functions assigned to each gene product align with known roles of these proteins from literature and UniProt - Trio as a GEF, Rac1 as a GTPase, and Dvl1 as a regulator of small GTPases.

  3. Causal reasoning: The directionality of causal relationships aligns with known biological mechanisms, with GEF activity properly regulating GTPase activity.

  4. Parsimony: The model captures key relationships without unnecessary complexity.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Incomplete annotation of cdh11: Cadherin-11 (Xenbase:XB-GENE-17340654) is only annotated with a generic molecular function (GO:0003674) rather than its specific function such as calcium-dependent cell adhesion activity.

  2. Missing cellular context: While this model represents molecular function and causal relationships, it would benefit from including cellular component context for these activities (where in the cell these activities occur).

  3. Biological process context: Though the title mentions neural crest cell migration, the model doesn't explicitly represent the biological processes these activities are part of (e.g., cell migration, cytoskeletal organization).

  4. Incomplete representation of pathway: According to the referenced paper, the pathway involves additional components like filopodia and lamellipodia formation that aren't represented in this model.

Consistency with GO-CAM Guidelines

  1. Complex representation: The model doesn't explicitly represent protein complexes, which appears appropriate based on the paper and "How to annotate complexes in GO-CAM" guidelines, as individual proteins with their specific activities are modeled.

  2. Causal relations: The model uses the appropriate causal predicates (RO:0002629 - directly positively regulates), adhering to GO-CAM best practices.

  3. Signaling pathway representation: The model could better follow "Signaling receptor activity annotation guidelines" by making the signaling flow more explicit if applicable to this pathway.

Biological Accuracy

Based on my review of the referenced publication (PMID:32366678), the model accurately captures key aspects of the described pathway. The paper demonstrates that:

  1. Trio is required for cranial neural crest cell migration in Xenopus
  2. Trio functions in protrusion formation by interacting with Dvl and activating Rac1
  3. Cadherin-11 (cdh11) interacts with this pathway
  4. Dvl activity is important for Trio's effects on neural crest cell migration

The model correctly represents these relationships, though it simplifies the full complexity described in the paper, which includes additional mechanisms such as: - Trio interacting with Dvl via its GEF2 domain - This interaction affecting protrusion formation and migration - Multiple additional interactions with proteins like Par3 and other signaling components

Recommendations for Improvement

  1. Add specific molecular function to cdh11: Replace the generic molecular function (GO:0003674) with a more specific annotation reflecting its known role in calcium-dependent cell adhesion.

  2. Add cellular component annotations: Include cellular locations for activities, such as cell membrane, filopodia, or lamellipodia where these proteins function.

  3. Add biological process context: Include explicit annotations to biological processes like "neural crest cell migration" (GO:0001755) or "filopodium assembly" (GO:0046847) that these activities are part of.

  4. Expand pathway representation: Consider adding additional components mentioned in the paper, such as the specific mechanism by which Trio and Dvl interact to activate Rac1, and the role of this pathway in filopodia and lamellipodia formation.

  5. Complete signaling flow: The model would benefit from explicitly representing the complete signaling cascade from Cadherin-11 to cytoskeletal remodeling.

Overall Assessment

This GO-CAM model provides a good representation of key molecular activities and causal relationships involved in Trio, Dvl1, and Cadherin-11 function in Xenopus neural crest cell migration. The model is consistent with the available evidence and follows GO-CAM guidelines. However, it could be enhanced by providing more specific functional annotations, cellular context, and additional pathway components to more fully capture the biological complexity described in the literature.

The model serves as a valuable resource for understanding this particular signaling pathway in neural crest cells, though with the suggested improvements it could be even more informative.