Skip to content

62b4ffe300003747 Response to IFN beta leading to JAK STAT activation Human

Based on the model and the guidelines, let me now conduct a thorough review of the GO-CAM model "Response to IFN-beta, leading to JAK-STAT activation (Human)" (gomodel:62b4ffe300003747).

GO-CAM Review: Response to IFN-beta, leading to JAK-STAT activation (Human)

Model Overview

This GO-CAM model (gomodel:62b4ffe300003747) represents the interferon-beta (IFN-beta) signaling pathway leading to JAK-STAT activation in humans. The model captures the cascade of molecular events from IFN-beta cytokine activity through receptor binding, JAK kinase activation, and ultimately to STAT transcription factor activation.

Assessment of Model Structure and Content

1. Molecular Function and Cellular Component Annotations

✅ Appropriate MF terms: The model correctly uses appropriate molecular function terms for each protein: - IFN-beta (P01574) → cytokine activity (GO:0005125) - IFNAR1 (P17181) and IFNAR2 (P48551) → type I interferon receptor activity (GO:0004905) - JAK1 (P23458) and TYK2 (P29597) → non-membrane spanning protein tyrosine kinase activity (GO:0004715) - STAT1 (P42224) and STAT2 (P52630) → DNA-binding transcription factor activity (GO:0000981)

✅ Appropriate CC terms: The model correctly uses appropriate cellular component terms: - IFN-beta occurs in extracellular space (GO:0005615) - Receptors occur in plasma membrane (GO:0005886) - TYK2 in one case occurs in "extrinsic component of plasma membrane" (GO:0019897) - STAT proteins occur in nucleus (GO:0005634)

2. Biological Process Annotations

✅ Appropriate BP terms: Each activity is part of relevant biological processes: - IFN-beta is part of cytokine-mediated signaling pathway (GO:0019221) - Receptors are part of cellular response to interferon-beta (GO:0035458) - JAK kinases are part of cell surface receptor signaling pathway via JAK-STAT (GO:0007259) - STAT proteins are part of regulation of transcription by RNA polymerase II (GO:0006357)

3. Causal Relationships

✅ Appropriate causal relations: The model uses "directly positively regulates" (RO:0002629) consistently for causal relationships between activities, which is the correct predicate for this signaling pathway.

The causal flow in the model follows the expected pattern for IFN-beta/JAK-STAT signaling: 1. IFN-beta cytokine activity → IFNAR1 and IFNAR2 receptor activity 2. Receptor activities → JAK kinase activities (TYK2, JAK1) 3. JAK kinase activities → STAT transcription factor activities

4. Evidence and References

✅ Evidence codes: The model uses appropriate evidence codes (ECO:0000314 for direct assay and ECO:0000304 for author statement) with corresponding PMID references.

References used: PMID:6157094, PMID:7813427, PMID:7759950, PMID:8232552, PMID:34813358, PMID:7657660, PMID:7526154, PMID:8605876, PMID:9020188, PMID:28753426, PMID:23139419, PMID:14532120

Areas for Improvement

  1. Redundant Causal Connections: There appear to be some duplicate causal relationships in the model:
  2. TYK2 (gomodel:62b4ffe300003747/62b4ffe300003871) has two identical causal connections to IFNAR1 (gomodel:62b4ffe300003747/62b4ffe300003911)

  3. JAK1 (gomodel:62b4ffe300003747/62b4ffe300003846) has two causal connections to the same downstream activity, with one lacking evidence

  4. JAK Pathway Signal Transduction Adaptor Activity: The model uses both receptor activity (GO:0004905) and JAK pathway signal transduction adaptor activity (GO:0008269) for the same proteins (IFNAR1 and IFNAR2) in different parts of the model. This dual annotation may be confusing - it would be helpful to clarify the precise role of these proteins in each context.

  5. Receptor Complex Representation: According to the complex annotation guidelines, the interferon receptor is typically a heterodimeric complex of IFNAR1 and IFNAR2. While the model represents both proteins separately with their respective activities, it might be clearer to represent their interaction explicitly.

Consistency with Literature

The model appears to be consistent with the established understanding of IFN-beta signaling via the JAK-STAT pathway. The key interactions are well-supported by the cited literature, which includes classic papers on interferon signaling.

Recommendation

This GO-CAM model provides a comprehensive representation of IFN-beta signaling via the JAK-STAT pathway and follows GO-CAM best practices for the most part. I would recommend accepting this model with minor revisions:

  1. Remove redundant causal connections between activities to improve clarity
  2. Consider clarifying the role of IFNAR1 and IFNAR2 with respect to their dual annotations as receptors and adaptors
  3. Consider adding a comment to explicitly note the heterodimeric nature of the interferon receptor complex

Overall, this is a well-constructed model that accurately represents the biological process of interferon-beta signaling through the JAK-STAT pathway in humans.