Skip to content

Based on my review of the model and related information, I'll now provide a comprehensive assessment of the GO-CAM model "gomodel:62b4ffe300004209" which represents the terrequinone A biosynthesis pathway in Emericella nidulans (Aspergillus nidulans).

GO-CAM Review: Terrequinone A biosynthesis (Emericella nidulans)

Model Summary

  • Model ID: gomodel:62b4ffe300004209
  • Title: Terrequinone A biosynthesis (Emericella nidulans)
  • Taxon: NCBITaxon:227321 (Emericella nidulans)
  • Status: Production

Overview

This model represents the biosynthetic pathway for terrequinone A, an antitumor fungal metabolite produced by Aspergillus nidulans (Emericella nidulans). The pathway involves five enzymes (TdiA-TdiE) that catalyze the conversion of L-tryptophan to terrequinone A through a series of reactions including aminotransferase activity, non-ribosomal peptide synthesis, oxidoreduction, and prenyltransferase activities.

Biological Accuracy

The model accurately captures the terrequinone A biosynthetic pathway as described in the literature (PMID:17704773 and PMID:18029206). The pathway proceeds through:

  1. TdiD (A7XRY8) - L-tryptophan aminotransferase that converts L-tryptophan to indole-3-pyruvate (IPA)
  2. TdiA (A7XRY0) - Non-ribosomal peptide synthase that dimerizes two IPA molecules to form didemethylasterriquinone D
  3. TdiB (A7XRY3) - Prenyltransferase that adds a prenyl group to didemethylasterriquinone D
  4. TdiC (A7XRY6) - NADH-dependent oxidoreductase that enables the next prenylation step
  5. TdiE (A7XRZ1) - Catalytic activity that helps convert intermediates to terrequinone A

The causal relationships represented in the model correctly show the flow of activities in the pathway: - TdiD provides input for TdiA (RO:0002413) - TdiA provides input for TdiB (RO:0002413) - TdiB provides input for TdiC (RO:0002413) - TdiC provides input for TdiE (RO:0002413)

Technical Assessment

Strengths:

  1. Accurate representation of the biochemical pathway based on experimental evidence
  2. Properly annotated molecular functions for each protein
  3. Appropriate causal relationships between activities (using RO:0002413 "provides input for")
  4. All activities associated with the correct biological process (GO:1900796 "terrequinone A biosynthetic process")
  5. Consistent use of evidence codes and PMIDs to support annotations
  6. Inclusion of input and output molecules for key steps in the pathway

Suggestions for improvement:

  1. Missing Inputs/Outputs: While some activities have has_input and has_output associations, others are missing these details. For example:
  2. TdiA should explicitly show has_input for indole-3-pyruvate (CHEBI:17640)
  3. TdiB should show has_input for didemethylasterriquinone D
  4. TdiC's inputs and outputs could be clarified

  5. TdiE's inputs and outputs should be specified

  6. Complex Formation: The papers describe how TdiB, TdiC, and TdiE work together to convert didemethylasterriquinone D to terrequinone A. The model could potentially benefit from representing this as a complex or at least indicating their cooperative activity more explicitly according to GO-CAM complex annotation guidelines.

  7. Intermediate Products: The model could more explicitly represent the formation of asterriquinone C-1 (an intermediate between didemethylasterriquinone D and terrequinone A).

  8. NADH/NADPH Cofactor: For TdiC, the model could explicitly represent the dependence on NADH/NADPH as a cofactor.

  9. Activity Details: TdiE is annotated with a general "catalytic activity" (GO:0003824), but based on the literature, a more specific function could potentially be assigned to better reflect its role in the pathway.

Evidence Support

The model uses appropriate evidence codes: - ECO:0000314 (direct assay evidence used in manual assertion) - ECO:0000315 (mutant phenotype evidence used in manual assertion)

The evidence is supported by key publications that describe the biochemical characterization of the pathway: - PMID:17704773 - Detailed biochemical characterization of the pathway - PMID:18029206 - Specific characterization of TdiB prenyltransferase activity

Conclusion

This GO-CAM model provides an accurate representation of the terrequinone A biosynthetic pathway in Emericella nidulans. It correctly captures the enzymatic steps, molecular functions, and causal relationships between activities. The model is well-supported by experimental evidence from the literature.

The model could be enhanced by adding more details about inputs/outputs for each step and potentially representing the cooperative activity of TdiB, TdiC, and TdiE more explicitly. However, overall the model is biologically accurate, technically sound, and provides valuable information about this fungal secondary metabolite biosynthetic pathway.