Skip to content

Based on my review of the GO-CAM model 62f58d8800004529 "Positive regulation of insulin secretion 6 (Mouse)", let me provide a comprehensive assessment:

GO-CAM Model Review: gomodel:62f58d8800004529

Summary

This model represents the positive regulation of insulin secretion in mouse, focusing on a cAMP-dependent pathway involving GLP-1 receptor signaling and downstream molecular events leading to insulin secretion. The model was created in 2022 and describes interactions among several key proteins including GLP-1 receptor (Glp1r), G proteins (Gnas, Rap1a, Rap1b), adenylate cyclase (Adcy8), cAMP-regulated guanine nucleotide exchange factor (Rapgef4/EPAC2), and Rim2 (Rims2), culminating in insulin secretion.

Strengths

  1. Biological accuracy: The model correctly represents a well-documented pathway of GLP-1 receptor-mediated insulin secretion, consistent with the literature referenced (PMID:11056535).

  2. Causal relationships: The causal relationships between activities are generally well-defined using the appropriate predicates (RO:0002629 "directly positively regulates").

  3. Evidence: Each assertion is backed by experimental evidence with appropriate ECO codes and PMIDs.

  4. Completeness: The model captures the full pathway from ligand-receptor interaction to the effector function (insulin secretion).

Issues and Recommendations

  1. Molecular adaptor annotation:
  2. Rapgef4 (MGI:MGI:1917723) is shown with two separate activities: guanyl-nucleotide exchange factor activity (GO:0005085) and protein-macromolecule adaptor activity (GO:0030674).
  3. According to the "How to annotate molecular adaptors" guidelines, an adaptor should include "has input" annotations for the molecules it brings together. The current model doesn't specify these inputs for the adaptor activity.

  4. Recommendation: Add "has_input" relationships to specify which molecules Rapgef4 brings together when functioning as an adaptor.

  5. Cellular compartment annotations:

  6. While some activities have "occurs_in" compartment annotations, not all do. For instance, GCG (glucagon) activity lacks a cellular location.

  7. Recommendation: Add appropriate cellular compartment information for all activities where known.

  8. Minor annotation inconsistencies:

  9. The Rims2 protein (MGI:MGI:2152972) has "molecular_function" annotated as GO:0003674 (molecular function), which is a root term. This is generally not recommended as it doesn't provide specific functional information.

  10. Recommendation: If the specific molecular function is known, replace GO:0003674 with a more specific term.

  11. Pathway visualization consideration:

  12. The model includes parallel pathways with Rap1a and Rap1b, which both perform G protein activity. This is biologically accurate but might make the model slightly more complex to interpret.

  13. Recommendation: Consider adding a comment to clarify the functional redundancy of these two proteins in this pathway.

  14. Literature integration:

  15. While the model cites PMID:11056535 which provides evidence for the Rapgef4-Rims2 interaction, it would be valuable to integrate more recent literature that may have further characterized this pathway.
  16. Recommendation: Consider updating the model with more recent references if available.

Technical Assessment

The model correctly implements GO-CAM best practices regarding: - Use of proper molecular function terms - Appropriate causal relationship predicates - Connection of activities to create a coherent biological pathway - Grounding assertions in experimental evidence - Species-specificity (correctly annotated as mouse)

Conclusion

Overall, this is a well-constructed GO-CAM model that accurately represents the current understanding of GLP-1 receptor-mediated insulin secretion in mouse pancreatic beta cells. The model provides a valuable resource for understanding this signaling pathway. With minor improvements to the annotations as suggested above, it would be even more comprehensive and useful to the research community.

The model can be accessed at: https://bioregistry.io/go.model:62f58d8800004529