Skip to content

633b013300001238 Pyruvate catabolic process 1 Mouse

Now, let me review this GO-CAM model based on all the information I've gathered:

Review of GO-CAM Model gomodel:633b013300001238 - "Pyruvate catabolic process 1 (Mouse)"

Model Overview:

This model represents the pyruvate catabolic process in mouse, focusing on lactate dehydrogenase activities and lactate transport. The model includes:

  1. Pyruvate kinase activity (Pkm) that provides input for lactate dehydrogenase activity
  2. Three lactate dehydrogenase activities (Ldha, Ldhb, Ldhc) that convert pyruvate to lactate in the cytosol
  3. Two lactate transmembrane transporters (Slc16a1/MCT1 and Slc16a3/MCT4) that export lactate from the cell

Strengths of the Model:

  1. Correct biological pathway representation: The model accurately represents the canonical glycolytic endpoint where pyruvate is converted to lactate and then exported from the cell.

  2. Appropriate use of causal relationships: The model uses the "provides input for" (RO:0002413) relationship appropriately to connect the pyruvate kinase activity to lactate dehydrogenase activities.

  3. Correct GO term usage: The model uses the appropriate molecular function terms for each protein (pyruvate kinase activity, L-lactate dehydrogenase activity, lactate transmembrane transporter activity).

  4. Proper cellular localization: The model correctly specifies the subcellular locations for the activities (cytosol for LDH activities, plasma membrane for transporters).

  5. Good evidence support: The model includes appropriate evidence codes and PMID references for most annotations.

Issues and Recommendations:

  1. Incomplete part_of annotations: The Ldhb activity (gomodel:633b013300001238/633b013300001437) lacks evidence for its involvement in the pyruvate catabolic process. An evidence code and reference should be added to support this annotation.

  2. Missing biological context: The model doesn't clearly indicate the physiological context in which this pathway operates. It would benefit from annotations showing when this pathway is activated (e.g., during anaerobic conditions, high glycolytic flux, etc.).

  3. Missing final destination: The model shows lactate being transported across the plasma membrane but doesn't indicate where it goes after export. Adding information about lactate's fate in the extracellular space or bloodstream would improve the model's completeness.

  4. Missing regulation: The model lacks regulatory components that control lactate dehydrogenase and transporter activities. For example, pH, NAD+/NADH ratio, and oxygen levels are important regulators of this pathway.

  5. Missing connection to downstream metabolism: While the model properly represents lactate export, it doesn't show potential reuptake and utilization of lactate by other cells (the lactate shuttle concept), which would provide a more complete biological picture.

Technical Compliance Issues:

  1. Complex representation: According to the "How to annotate complexes in GO-CAM" guidelines, the LDH activities would be better represented if their functional relationship as potential tetramers was indicated. LDH typically functions as a tetramer composed of different combinations of LDHA, LDHB, and LDHC subunits.

  2. Causal chain completeness: While the pyruvate kinase is shown to provide input for LDHC, there should be a direct causal relationship to the other LDH activities (LDHA, LDHB) as well, especially since all these LDH activities are part of the same process.

Suggested Improvements:

  1. Add evidence for Ldhb's involvement in the pyruvate catabolic process
  2. Add regulatory relationships that control the lactate dehydrogenase activities
  3. Expand the model to include the fate of exported lactate
  4. Consider representing the LDH enzymes' relationship as part of functional tetramers
  5. Add direct causal relationships between the pyruvate kinase activity and all LDH activities
  6. Include information about NAD+/NADH involvement in the LDH reaction

This model provides a good foundation for representing the pyruvate to lactate conversion pathway in mouse, but could be enhanced with the suggested improvements to provide a more complete biological representation of this important metabolic process.