Skip to content

Based on the information gathered, I'll now review the GO-CAM model for "Coenzyme A biosynthetic process 1 (Mouse)" (gomodel:645d887900000340).

Review of GO-CAM Model: Coenzyme A biosynthetic process 1 (Mouse)

Model Summary

This model represents the Coenzyme A (CoA) biosynthetic pathway in mouse, including the enzymatic activities and transport steps required for CoA biosynthesis. The model includes multiple gene products, their molecular functions, cellular locations, and causal relationships showing the flow of the pathway.

Biological Content Assessment

The model accurately represents the canonical CoA biosynthetic pathway, which consists of five enzymatic steps: 1. Pantothenate kinase (PANK1/PANK2) - converts pantothenate to 4'-phosphopantothenate 2. Phosphopantothenoylcysteine synthetase (PPCS) - forms 4'-phosphopantothenoylcysteine 3. Phosphopantothenoylcysteine decarboxylase (PPCDC) - produces 4'-phosphopantetheine 4. Pantetheine-phosphate adenylyltransferase activity (COASY) - forms dephospho-CoA 5. Dephospho-CoA kinase activity (COASY) - produces the final CoA

Additionally, the model includes appropriate transporters: - SLC5A6 (pantothenate:sodium symporter) - SLC25A16 and SLC25A42 (mitochondrial transporters)

Strengths

  1. Comprehensive pathway representation: The model accurately covers all key steps of CoA biosynthesis.
  2. Proper causal connections: The activities are connected with the appropriate "provides input for" (RO:0002413) causal relation showing pathway flow.
  3. Consistent cellular locations: Each activity is appropriately localized (cytosol, mitochondrial membranes, etc.).
  4. Well-evidenced annotations: The model uses appropriate evidence codes (ECO terms) and references (PMIDs) for the assertions.
  5. Proper regulation: The model includes PDZD11 as an enzyme activator of SLC5A6.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Missing chemical entities: While the activities are well-connected, the model doesn't explicitly show the metabolic intermediates as chemical entities. According to best practices, including the ChEBI terms for substrates and products would enhance the model.

  2. Transporter annotations: The transporters (SLC5A6, SLC25A16, SLC25A42) are included, but according to the transporter activity annotation guidelines, it would be ideal to explicitly represent:

  3. The specific molecules being transported

  4. The start and end locations of the transported molecules

  5. COASY dual function: The protein COASY (MGI:MGI:1918993) correctly has two separate activities (pantetheine-phosphate adenylyltransferase and dephospho-CoA kinase) but it could be clearer that this is a bifunctional enzyme.

  6. Missing "occurs_in" annotation: Some activities don't have an "occurs_in" relation to specify their cellular location, though most do.

  7. Limited pathway context: While the biosynthetic pathway is well-represented, the model could benefit from connections to processes that utilize CoA.

Technical Assessment

  1. Predicates: The model correctly uses RO:0002413 (provides input for) to connect sequential activities in the pathway, and RO:0002629 (directly positively regulates) for the regulatory relationship.

  2. Evidence codes: The model uses appropriate evidence codes including:

  3. ECO:0000314 (direct assay evidence)
  4. ECO:0000315 (mutant phenotype evidence)
  5. ECO:0000316 (genetic interaction evidence)

  6. ECO:0000266 (sequence orthology evidence)

  7. References: Each assertion is supported by PMIDs.

Overall Assessment

This is a high-quality GO-CAM model that accurately represents the CoA biosynthetic pathway in mouse. It follows the major GO-CAM best practices for pathway representation and provides appropriate evidence for the assertions. The few suggested improvements would enhance the model but are not critical flaws. The model is parsimonious and presents a clear flow of the pathway that would be understandable to other researchers.

You can view this model at: https://bioregistry.io/go.model:645d887900000340