Skip to content

645d887900000999 BMP7 signaling leading to osteoblast differentiation Human

Based on my review of the GO-CAM model gomodel:645d887900000999 titled "BMP7 signaling leading to osteoblast differentiation (Human)" and the relevant GO-CAM documentation, I can provide the following assessment:

Summary of the Model

This model represents the BMP7 signaling pathway leading to osteoblast differentiation in humans. The pathway begins with BMP7 (P18075) in the extracellular space, which initiates signaling through type II receptor ACVR2A (P27037) which then activates type I receptor ACVR1 (Q04771). This activation leads to transcription factor activation (SMAD1, SMAD5, and SMAD9) in the nucleus, ultimately regulating osteoblast differentiation genes.

Strengths of the Model

  1. Correct pathway structure: The model correctly represents the canonical BMP signaling pathway, where BMP7 acts as a growth factor that binds to and activates type II receptors, which then phosphorylate and activate type I receptors, which in turn phosphorylate SMADs that translocate to the nucleus and regulate gene expression.

  2. Appropriate molecular functions: Each protein is annotated with the correct molecular function:

  3. BMP7 has "growth factor activity" (GO:0008083)
  4. ACVR2A has "activin receptor activity, type II" (GO:0016362)
  5. ACVR1 has "activin receptor activity, type I" (GO:0016361)

  6. SMAD proteins have transcription factor activities (GO:0000981, GO:0001228)

  7. Correct cellular locations: Each activity is properly localized:

  8. BMP7 in extracellular space (GO:0005615)
  9. Receptors in plasma membrane (GO:0005886)

  10. Transcription factors in nucleus (GO:0005634) or chromatin (GO:0000785)

  11. Correct causal relationships: The model uses the appropriate causal relationships between activities:

  12. BMP7 "directly positively regulates" (RO:0002629) ACVR2A, which aligns with the guidelines for protein ligand-activated signaling receptor pathways
  13. ACVR2A "directly positively regulates" ACVR1

  14. ACVR1 "directly positively regulates" the transcription factors

  15. Biological accuracy: The model accurately represents the known biology of BMP7 signaling, consistent with the information from UniProt entries.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Missing Biological Process annotation: While all activities are correctly annotated as part of "BMP signaling pathway" (GO:0030509), there is no explicit representation of "osteoblast differentiation" (GO:0001649) despite it being mentioned in the title. This process should be included as a downstream effect of the transcription factor activities.

  2. Incomplete representation of SMAD complex formation: According to the UniProt entry for SMAD1, it forms a complex with SMAD4 which is crucial for nuclear translocation and transcriptional activity. The model doesn't include SMAD4, which is an important part of the canonical BMP signaling pathway.

  3. Limited downstream effects: The model stops at the transcription factors' activities without showing which specific genes they regulate to promote osteoblast differentiation. Including target genes would make the model more complete.

  4. Missing evidence for some annotations: While most activities have experimental evidence codes (ECO:0000314 - direct assay evidence), some rely on sequence similarity or computational analysis. When available, direct experimental evidence would strengthen the model.

Recommendations for Improvement

  1. Add GO:0001649 (osteoblast differentiation) as a biological process that is causally downstream of the transcription factor activities.

  2. Include SMAD4 and its interaction with SMAD1, SMAD5, and SMAD9 to form transcriptionally active complexes.

  3. Expand the model to include specific target genes regulated by the SMAD transcription factors that are involved in osteoblast differentiation.

  4. Check for additional direct experimental evidence for annotations that currently rely on sequence similarity or computational prediction.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model gomodel:645d887900000999 provides a solid representation of the BMP7 signaling pathway leading to transcription factor activation. It correctly follows GO-CAM best practices for representing signaling pathways and receptor activities. With the suggested improvements, particularly the inclusion of osteoblast differentiation as a biological process and SMAD4 as a co-SMAD, the model would more comprehensively represent the pathway described in its title.

The model is biologically accurate and follows the GO-CAM guidelines for signaling receptor activity. It correctly shows the flow of information from extracellular signal (BMP7) through membrane receptors (ACVR2A and ACVR1) to nuclear transcription factors (SMAD proteins), which is the canonical mechanism of BMP signaling.