Skip to content

Based on my review, I'll now provide a thorough assessment of this GO-CAM model.

Review of Biotin Metabolic Process 1 (Mouse) GO-CAM Model

Model Overview

The GO-CAM model (gomodel:6482692800001393) describes a biotin metabolic process in mouse, specifically focusing on the role of holocarboxylase synthetase (Hlcs) in the biotinylation of carboxylases and the subsequent functional effects.

Model Components

The model consists of several key activities:

  1. Biotin-protein ligase activity (GO:0004077) - carried out by Hlcs (MGI:MGI:894646) in biotin metabolic process (GO:0006768)
  2. Has biotin (CHEBI:15956) as input

  3. Positively regulates two downstream activities:

    • Acetyl-CoA carboxylase activity (GO:0003989) of Acaca (MGI:MGI:108451)
    • Pyruvate carboxylase activity (GO:0004736) of Pcx (MGI:MGI:97520) in gluconeogenesis (GO:0006094)

  4. Molecular function activator activity (GO:0140677) - carried out by Pdzd11 (MGI:MGI:1919871) at the plasma membrane (GO:0005886)

  5. Positively regulates the sodium-dependent multivitamin transmembrane transporter activity

  6. Sodium-dependent multivitamin transmembrane transporter activity (GO:0008523) - carried out by Slc5a6 (MGI:MGI:2660847) at the plasma membrane

  7. Has biotin as primary input
  8. Provides input for the Hlcs biotin-protein ligase activity

Strengths of the Model

  1. Comprehensive pathway representation: The model effectively captures the biotin transport, biotinylation of carboxylases, and subsequent metabolic activities.

  2. Well-supported evidence: The model cites appropriate literature evidence, including PMID:35385533 for Hlcs activity, PMID:21183659 for Pdzd11 activity, and PMID:23104561 for Slc5a6 activity.

  3. Appropriate causal relationships: The model correctly uses "RO:0002629" (directly positively regulates) and "RO:0002413" (provides input for) to show the flow of regulation and substrates.

  4. Cellular context inclusion: Appropriate cellular locations are specified for activities (e.g., plasma membrane for transporters).

Issues and Recommendations

  1. Missing bioprocess annotations: While Acaca has an activity annotation, it lacks a specific biological process annotation. Given its role, it could be annotated as part of "fatty acid biosynthetic process" (GO:0006633).

  2. Recent evidence update: The model has a comment "Automated change 2024-06-27: GO:0018271 replaced by GO:0004077" - this update was correctly implemented.

  3. Missing cellular component for Hlcs: The UniProt entry for Hlcs indicates it's located in both the cytoplasm and mitochondrion, but no cellular component is specified in the model. Adding this would improve the spatial representation.

  4. Expansion opportunity: The literature suggests Hlcs may also biotinylate histones, which could be included in an expanded version of this model.

  5. Potential missing regulation: The literature suggests biotin levels adaptively regulate intestinal uptake of biotin, which could be represented as an additional regulatory relationship in the model.

Scientific Accuracy

The model accurately represents the current scientific understanding of biotin metabolism:

  1. Biotin is transported into the cell by the sodium-dependent multivitamin transporter (Slc5a6)
  2. Hlcs catalyzes the biotinylation of carboxylases
  3. Biotinylated carboxylases (Acaca, Pcx) can perform their respective metabolic functions

The supporting evidence from the cited papers confirms these relationships and the importance of Hlcs for proper carboxylase function, with knockout studies showing embryonic lethality.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model "Biotin Metabolic Process 1 (Mouse)" is a well-constructed representation of biotin metabolism that adheres to most GO-CAM best practices. It effectively captures the flow of biotin from transport into the cell through its incorporation into carboxylases and the resulting metabolic activities.

Minor improvements could include: 1. Adding cellular component annotations for Hlcs 2. Including biological process annotations for all activities 3. Possibly expanding to include histone biotinylation

Overall, this model provides a valuable representation of biotin metabolism and should be valuable for researchers studying this important pathway.