Skip to content

Based on my review, I'll now provide a detailed assessment of GO-CAM model gomodel:64e7eefa00001233, which represents "Extrinsic apoptotic signaling pathway via death domain receptors 1 (Mouse)".

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:64e7eefa00001233

Model Overview

This model represents the extrinsic apoptotic signaling pathway via death domain receptors in mouse, focusing on the TNF (Tumor Necrosis Factor) pathway leading to apoptosis. The model captures the causal chain from TNF ligand binding to its receptor through adapter proteins to caspase activation.

Model Strengths

  1. Appropriate pathway representation: The model correctly captures the key components of the TNF-mediated extrinsic apoptotic pathway, from ligand-receptor binding to downstream signaling events.

  2. Cellular locations: The model appropriately assigns cellular locations to the molecular functions, with TNF and its receptor at the plasma membrane (GO:0005886) and the adaptor proteins and caspases in the cytosol (GO:0005829).

  3. Proper causal relationships: The model uses appropriate causal relationships (RO:0002413 "provides input for" and RO:0002629 "directly positively regulates") to connect the activities in the pathway.

  4. Evidence support: Most activities and causal links are supported by experimental evidence with appropriate ECO codes and PMIDs.

Issues and Recommendations

1. TNF Receptor Activity Annotation

Issue: The TNF receptor (Tnfrsf1a) is correctly annotated with "tumor necrosis factor receptor activity" (GO:0005031) and is shown as regulated by TNF through the "directly positively regulates" relationship. However, the molecular function has no input specified.

Recommendation: According to the signaling receptor activity guidelines, the receptor should have its downstream effector (TRADD in this case) as input. Modify the model to add "has input" relationship between the receptor activity and TRADD.

2. Missing Biological Process for TNF

Issue: While TNF is annotated as part of "positive regulation of execution phase of apoptosis" (GO:1900119), it would be more accurate to also associate it with a more specific term related to TNF signaling.

Recommendation: Consider annotating TNF to "tumor necrosis factor-mediated signaling pathway" (GO:0033209) or a more specific child term to better reflect its primary role in the pathway.

3. TRADD and FADD Annotations

Issue: Both TRADD and FADD are annotated with the generic "signaling adaptor activity" (GO:0035591), which is correct but could be more specific.

Recommendation: Consider using a more specific child term like "death domain binding" (GO:0070513) for both proteins to better reflect their specific role in death receptor signaling. This would enhance the specificity of the model.

4. RIPK1 Protein Kinase Activity

Issue: RIPK1 is correctly annotated with "protein kinase activity" (GO:0004672), but this is a broad term that doesn't capture its specific role.

Recommendation: Consider using the more specific term "protein serine/threonine kinase activity" (GO:0004674) or even "death domain containing receptor interacting serine/threonine kinase activity" (GO:0097110) if appropriate.

5. Pathway Context

Issue: The overall biological process for most activities is annotated as "positive regulation of execution phase of apoptosis" (GO:1900119), but the model actually represents the extrinsic apoptotic signaling pathway.

Recommendation: Consider annotating the activities to "extrinsic apoptotic signaling pathway" (GO:0097191) or, more specifically, "extrinsic apoptotic signaling pathway via death domain receptors" (GO:0008625), which would better reflect the primary biological process being modeled.

6. Complex Annotation Issue

Issue: According to the "How to annotate complexes in GO-CAM" guidelines, when the subunit carrying the molecular activity is known (as in this case), the complex is not described and the activity is represented by the specific protein carrying it. The model follows this guideline correctly, but it doesn't capture that TRADD, FADD, RIPK1, and Caspase-8 can form a complex called the death-inducing signaling complex (DISC).

Recommendation: While the current representation is valid, consider adding a note or comment indicating that these proteins form the DISC complex in this context. This would provide additional valuable information without changing the model structure.

Conclusion

Overall, model gomodel:64e7eefa00001233 is a well-structured representation of the TNF-mediated extrinsic apoptotic pathway in mouse. It correctly captures the key molecular functions, their cellular locations, and the causal relationships between them. The issues identified are mostly related to the specificity of the GO terms used and the context of the pathway, rather than fundamental errors in the model structure.

The model effectively shows how TNF binding to its receptor initiates a signaling cascade through TRADD, RIPK1, and FADD to activate Caspase-8, ultimately leading to the execution phase of apoptosis. With the suggested improvements, the model would provide an even more precise and informative representation of this important biological pathway.