Skip to content

Based on my review of model gomodel:65288b2200000194 "STING1 acts as a proton channel and promotes autophagosome assembly (Human)", I can provide the following assessment:

Review of GO-CAM model: 65288b2200000194

Model Overview

This model represents the role of STING1 (Stimulator of Interferon Genes protein) as a proton channel that promotes autophagosome assembly in humans. The model connects several key proteins involved in the autophagy pathway, including ATG4B, ATG4C, ATG4D, ATG5, and MAP1LC3B.

Strengths

  1. Scientific Accuracy: The model accurately represents recent findings about STING1's function as a proton channel, specifically based on the 2023 publication (PMID:37535724) that identified this function.

  2. Molecular Functions: Appropriate molecular functions are assigned to each protein:

  3. STING1 is correctly annotated with proton channel activity (GO:0015252)
  4. ATG4 proteins (ATG4B, ATG4C, ATG4D) are annotated with appropriate protease activities
  5. ATG5 is annotated with ATG8-family ligase activity

  6. MAP1LC3B is annotated with phosphatidylethanolamine binding

  7. Localization: Cellular components are appropriately assigned:

  8. STING1 is correctly localized to the Golgi membrane (GO:0000139)
  9. ATG4B is correctly localized to autophagosome membrane (GO:0000421)
  10. MAP1LC3B is correctly localized to the autophagosome membrane

  11. ATG5 is correctly localized to the autophagosome

  12. Biological Process: All activities are appropriately part of the autophagosome assembly (GO:0000045) process.

  13. Causal Relationships: The model uses appropriate causal relationships to link activities:

  14. RO:0002629 (directly positively regulates) is used to connect the protease activities to MAP1LC3B activity
  15. RO:0002407 (is upstream of) connects STING1's proton channel activity to ATG5's ligase activity

Areas for Improvement

  1. Evidence Completeness: Several causal associations lack evidence annotations. For example, there's an unannotated causal association between ATG4C and MAP1LC3B.

  2. Missing Contextual Information: The model doesn't completely capture the mechanism by which STING1's proton channel activity promotes autophagosome formation. The specific pH changes in the Golgi and their consequences on autophagy machinery could be more explicitly represented.

  3. Connection Clarity: The connection between ATG5 and MAP1LC3B activity could be more detailed to represent the complete LC3 lipidation process, which involves additional proteins like ATG7 and ATG3 that are not included in this model.

Compliance with GO-CAM Guidelines

  1. Complex Annotation: The model follows GO-CAM guidelines for protein annotation, focusing on individual proteins rather than complexes when the specific subunits carrying activities are known.

  2. Causal Relationships: The model correctly uses the appropriate relationship predicates for connecting activities.

  3. Evidence Annotation: Most activities and relationships include proper evidence codes and literature references, though some causal associations lack evidence annotations.

Biological Accuracy

The model accurately represents current scientific understanding of STING1's role in autophagy based on recent literature. The 2023 paper (PMID:37535724) identified STING1 as a proton channel that facilitates autophagosome formation by promoting proton efflux from the Golgi, which is captured in this model.

The connection between ATG4 family proteins (ATG4B, ATG4C, ATG4D) cleaving the C-terminus of MAP1LC3B to expose the glycine residue needed for lipidation is biologically accurate. Similarly, ATG5's role in the lipidation process and MAP1LC3B's association with autophagosome membranes are correctly represented.

Recommendations

  1. Add evidence codes to all causal relationships.

  2. Consider expanding the model to include additional proteins in the autophagy pathway, such as ATG7 and ATG3, to provide a more complete representation of the LC3 lipidation process.

  3. Add additional annotations to clarify the mechanism by which STING1's proton channel activity influences autophagosome formation.

Conclusion

This GO-CAM model (gomodel:65288b2200000194) provides an accurate representation of STING1's role as a proton channel in promoting autophagosome assembly, consistent with current scientific literature. The model successfully captures the key proteins and their activities in this process, with appropriate molecular functions, cellular locations, and causal relationships. With minor improvements in evidence annotation and additional contextual details, this model would be an excellent reference for the field.