Skip to content

Based on my detailed review of the GO-CAM model "gomodel:65288b2200001218" titled "USP9X-TRIM32 modulation of IQCB1 during G1-S (Human)", I can now provide a comprehensive assessment.

GO-CAM Review: USP9X-TRIM32 modulation of IQCB1 during G1-S (Human)

Summary of the Model

This GO-CAM models the molecular interactions between three key proteins involved in ciliogenesis regulation: 1. IQCB1/NPHP5 (Q15051) - a centrosomal protein that regulates ciliogenesis 2. USP9X (Q93008) - a deubiquitinating enzyme 3. TRIM32 (Q13049) - an E3 ubiquitin ligase

The model shows how USP9X and TRIM32 regulate IQCB1 during the G1-S phase of the cell cycle through different types of ubiquitination, which controls cilium assembly. This is supported primarily by evidence from PMID:28498859.

Model Accuracy Assessment

Biological Content Evaluation

The model is biologically accurate and aligns well with the literature evidence. The central paper (PMID:28498859) describes how: - USP9X deubiquitinates NPHP5/IQCB1, protecting it from degradation during G0/G1/S phase - TRIM32 (BBS11) negatively regulates ciliogenesis by K63-linked ubiquitination of IQCB1, leading to its delocalization - These mechanisms are part of controlling cilia assembly/disassembly through the cell cycle

The GO-CAM correctly represents these interactions where: - USP9X's deubiquitinating activity (GO:0101005) directly positively regulates IQCB1's BBSome binding (GO:0062063) - TRIM32's E3 ligase activity (GO:0061630) directly negatively regulates IQCB1's BBSome binding - IQCB1 functions as a protein-macromolecule adaptor (GO:0030674) providing input for USP9X's activity

Molecular Function and Causal Relationship Evaluation

The MF and causal relationship annotations are appropriate: 1. USP9X's deubiquitinase activity (GO:0101005) → directly positively regulates (RO:0002629) → IQCB1's BBSome binding (GO:0062063) 2. TRIM32's ubiquitin ligase activity (GO:0061630) → directly negatively regulates (RO:0002630) → IQCB1's BBSome binding (GO:0062063) 3. IQCB1's adaptor activity (GO:0030674) → provides input for (RO:0002413) → USP9X's activity (GO:0101005)

These connections are well-supported by the evidence presented and use the correct relation predicates.

Spatial Localization Evaluation

The cellular locations are accurately represented: - All three proteins are correctly localized to the centrosome (GO:0005813) - This is substantiated by the experimental evidence provided

Biological Process Context Evaluation

The model correctly places these activities in the biological process context: - USP9X's and IQCB1's activities are part of cytosolic ciliogenesis (GO:0061824) - TRIM32's activity is part of negative regulation of cilium assembly (GO:1902018)

Both of these processes are accurately supported by the literature evidence.

Specific Issues and Improvement Recommendations

While the model is generally well-constructed, I identified a few potential improvements:

  1. Additional process contexts: The model could benefit from adding the cell cycle context (G1-S transition) mentioned in the title. The literature clearly describes how these interactions vary through the cell cycle, with USP9X protecting IQCB1 during G0/G1/S, and TRIM32 regulating it during G2/M.

  2. Complex representation: According to the GO-CAM complex annotation guidelines, if the subunit carrying an activity is known (as in this case), we should represent each protein individually rather than using a complex ID. The model correctly follows this guideline.

  3. Missing components: The literature mentions MARCH7 as another E3 ligase interacting with IQCB1, adding K48-linked ubiquitination leading to degradation. This component could potentially be added for completeness, although the current focus on TRIM32 is valid.

  4. Temporal dynamics: The model could better capture how ubiquitination and deubiquitination change through the cell cycle. The paper describes how USP9X dissociates from the centrosome in G2/M phase, which enables TRIM32 to K63-ubiquitinate IQCB1, triggering delocalization.

Overall Assessment

This GO-CAM model provides a clear and accurate representation of how USP9X and TRIM32 regulate IQCB1 in cilia formation. The model effectively: - Uses appropriate molecular functions for each protein - Correctly applies causal relationship predicates - Places activities in the proper cellular locations - Assigns activities to the correct biological processes

The modular nature of the model makes it easy to understand the regulatory relationships between these proteins, and the evidence provided substantiates all the assertions.

The model successfully captures a critical mechanism for regulating ciliogenesis, which has implications for understanding ciliopathies like Bardet-Biedl syndrome and Senior-Loken syndrome associated with mutations in TRIM32 and IQCB1, respectively.