Skip to content

After reviewing the model and relevant literature, I'll now provide a detailed review of GO-CAM model gomodel:65d7e4ac00002167 "Glycogen biosynthetic process (Dmel)":

GO-CAM Model Review: Glycogen Biosynthetic Process in Drosophila melanogaster

Model ID: gomodel:65d7e4ac00002167

Overall Summary

This model represents the glycogen biosynthetic pathway in Drosophila melanogaster, depicting the sequence of enzymatic activities that convert glucose phosphate to glycogen. The model includes five key activities carried out by five Drosophila proteins, with appropriate causal relationships connecting these activities.

Biological Content Assessment

The model correctly represents the canonical glycogen biosynthetic pathway, starting with phosphoglucomutase (Pgm1) converting glucose-6-phosphate to glucose-1-phosphate, followed by UGP (UTP:glucose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase) producing UDP-glucose, which is then used by Gyg (glycogenin) and Glys (glycogen synthase) to build glycogen, with Agbe (branching enzyme) providing branching activity.

The sequence of reactions and causal relationships is accurate and supported by the literature, particularly the paper by Yamada et al. (2019, PMID:30918052), which describes glycogen metabolism in Drosophila in detail.

Annotation Quality

  1. Evidence and References:
  2. Appropriate evidence codes are used for each annotation
  3. References include direct experimental papers specific to Drosophila (PMID:30918052, PMID:2943269) and sequence-based annotations

  4. Some annotations use sequence similarity evidence (ECO:0000250) with appropriate with_objects references

  5. Ontology Term Usage:

  6. Molecular function terms are correctly chosen for each enzyme
  7. All activities are correctly associated with the glycogen biosynthetic process (GO:0005978)

  8. Chemical entities are properly identified with CHEBI IDs

  9. Causal Relationships:

  10. Appropriate causal relationships (RO:0002413 - "provides input for") connect activities in correct metabolic order
  11. The flow of the pathway is logical and biologically accurate

Areas for Improvement

  1. Redundant Causal Associations:

  2. The Gyg (glycogenin) activity (65d7e4ac00002191) has two identical causal associations (RO:0002413) to the same downstream Glys activity (65d7e4ac00002198). One of these appears redundant and should be removed.

  3. Chemical Inputs/Outputs:

  4. The model could be more complete by including all substrate inputs for each reaction. For example, UTP should be listed as an input for the UGP activity.

  5. Evidence Consistency:

  6. Some evidence references have trailing spaces in their identifiers (e.g., "FB:FBrf0255270 | GO_REF:0000024 "), which should be cleaned up.

  7. Missing Regulation:

  8. The model focuses on the core pathway but doesn't include regulatory elements known to control glycogen synthesis, such as insulin signaling pathway components that regulate glycogen synthase.

Compliance with GO-CAM Guidelines

The model follows GO-CAM guidelines well, including: - Proper representation of causal relationships between activities - Appropriate use of occurs_in and part_of relations - Correct annotation of input/output molecules - Consistent use of evidence codes with references

The model does not use complexes, so complex annotation guidelines are not applicable in this case.

Conclusion

This is a well-constructed GO-CAM model that accurately represents the glycogen biosynthetic pathway in Drosophila melanogaster. The activities are properly connected through causal relationships, and the annotations are supported by appropriate evidence. The minor issues identified (redundant causal association, some missing inputs) do not significantly impact the biological accuracy of the model.

I recommend: 1. Removing one of the redundant causal associations from Gyg to Glys 2. Consider adding missing substrate inputs like UTP 3. Consider expanding the model to include regulatory elements in future iterations

With these minor adjustments, this model will serve as an excellent representation of glycogen biosynthesis in Drosophila.