Skip to content

Based on all the information gathered, I'll now review the GO-CAM model gomodel:65d7e4ac00002290 "Glycogen catabolic process (Dmel)".

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:65d7e4ac00002290 - Glycogen catabolic process (Dmel)

Overview

This model represents the glycogen catabolic process in Drosophila melanogaster (fruit fly) and includes three key enzymes involved in this metabolic pathway:

  1. Glycogen phosphorylase (Glyp) - FB:FBgn0004507
  2. Glycogen debranching enzyme (Agl) - FB:FBgn0034618
  3. Phosphoglucomutase (Pgm1) - FB:FBgn0003076

The model correctly represents the sequential enzymatic reactions in glycogen breakdown, with appropriate molecular functions, inputs/outputs, and causal relationships.

Strengths of the Model

  1. Accurate representation of the glycogen catabolic pathway: The model correctly captures the key enzymes and their sequential interactions in glycogen breakdown in Drosophila.

  2. Evidence support: Most activities are supported by appropriate evidence from the literature with cited PMIDs.

  3. Molecular details: The model includes specific inputs and outputs for each reaction, showing the molecular transformations occurring at each step.

  4. Cellular location: All activities are annotated to occur in the cytosol (GO:0005829), which is appropriate for glycogen metabolism.

  5. Causal connections: The model correctly depicts the flow of the pathway using the RO:0002413 "provides input for" relationship, showing how each enzyme's activity feeds into the next.

Suggestions for Improvement

  1. Redundant activities: There appear to be two nearly identical Glyp activities (gomodel:65d7e4ac00002290/65d7e4ac00002301 and gomodel:65d7e4ac00002290/65d7e4ac00002296). Both have the same molecular function (GO:0008184), occur in the same location (GO:0005829), are part of the same biological process (GO:0005980), and produce the same output (CHEBI:58601). This redundancy could be simplified to make the model more parsimonious.

  2. Completion of causal chain: The final step catalyzed by Pgm1 (phosphoglucomutase) converts alpha-D-glucose 1-phosphate to alpha-D-glucose 6-phosphate, but there's no indication of what happens next. Since glycogen catabolism ultimately feeds into glycolysis, it would be valuable to connect this to the glycolytic pathway or indicate that glucose-6-phosphate enters glycolysis.

  3. Missing regulation information: The model does not capture any regulatory mechanisms for glycogen phosphorylase activation. Based on the literature, Drosophila glycogen phosphorylase is regulated by phosphorylation (converting between the active "a" form and inactive "b" form). Adding this regulatory mechanism would enhance the model.

  4. Model comment clarification: The model has a comment "Copy from glycogen catabolic process (mouse)" which suggests it was adapted from a mouse model. The curator should verify that all Drosophila-specific aspects of glycogen metabolism have been properly represented.

Literature and Knowledge Consistency

The model aligns well with the literature on Drosophila glycogen metabolism:

  1. The papers by Dombradi et al. (PMID:3093145) provide detailed characterization of Drosophila glycogen phosphorylase.

  2. The sequential activities of glycogen phosphorylase, debranching enzyme, and phosphoglucomutase are consistent with established knowledge of glycogen breakdown.

  3. The model correctly represents that glycogen phosphorylase produces alpha-D-glucose 1-phosphate from glycogen.

  4. The location of these activities in the cytosol is consistent with where glycogen breakdown occurs.

Technical Accuracy

  1. All activities are properly connected with their respective molecular functions.

  2. Evidence codes are used appropriately.

  3. The causal associations are represented correctly using the "provides input for" relation (RO:0002413).

  4. The chemical entities are represented with appropriate ChEBI identifiers.

Conclusion

Overall, this is a well-structured GO-CAM model that accurately represents the glycogen catabolic process in Drosophila melanogaster. The model is consistent with the literature and follows GO-CAM best practices. The main areas for improvement involve eliminating redundancy (duplicated glycogen phosphorylase activities), potentially adding regulatory mechanisms, and completing the connection to downstream metabolic pathways.

This model provides a valuable resource for understanding glycogen metabolism in Drosophila and serves as a good example of how to represent metabolic pathways in GO-CAM.