Skip to content

Based on the information gathered, I'll now provide a detailed review of the GO-CAM model (gomodel:65f3ae5c00002270):

GO-CAM Model Review: gomodel:65f3ae5c00002270

Model Summary

  • Title: "Positive regulation of glycogen catabolic process 2 (Mouse)"
  • Taxon: Mouse (NCBITaxon:10090)
  • Status: Production
  • Contains: 7 activities representing a glycogen catabolic pathway in mouse

Overall Assessment

This GO-CAM model represents the glycogen catabolic process in mouse, specifically focusing on the activities of key enzymes involved in glycogen breakdown in the cytosol. The model includes appropriate molecular functions, cellular locations, and causal relationships between activities.

Strengths

  1. Biological accuracy: The model correctly represents the key enzymes involved in glycogen catabolism, including:
  2. Phkg1 (phosphorylase kinase gamma 1)
  3. Pygb (brain glycogen phosphorylase)
  4. Agl (glycogen debranching enzyme with dual activities)

  5. Pgm1 and Pgm2 (phosphoglucomutases)

  6. Causal relationships: The model appropriately uses "provides input for" (RO:0002413) and "directly positively regulates" (RO:0002629) predicates to connect activities in a biologically meaningful way.

  7. Evidence support: All activities are supported by experimental evidence with appropriate ECO codes and PMIDs.

  8. Proper representation of dual activity: The model correctly represents the dual enzymatic activities of the Agl protein (amylo-alpha-1,6-glucosidase and 4-alpha-glucanotransferase), which are important for glycogen debranching.

  9. Inclusion of final product: The model tracks the pathway through to the production of alpha-D-glucose 6-phosphate, which is the end product of glycogen breakdown.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Missing direct evidence for causal relationships: While the causal associations between activities (e.g., one enzyme's output feeding into another enzyme's activity) appear biologically correct, these associations lack direct evidence annotations. It would be beneficial to add evidence for these causal links.

  2. Duplicated Pygb activities: There are two instances of Pygb glycogen phosphorylase activity (nodes 65f3ae5c00002276 and 65f3ae5c00002283) with identical functions. This appears to be redundant and might confuse users of the model. Consider consolidating these into a single activity node.

  3. Biological process associations: Some activities are associated with the general "biological regulation" (GO:0065007) process rather than the more specific "glycogen catabolic process" (GO:0005980). For consistency, consider using the more specific process term throughout the model.

  4. Missing spatial information: While all activities are correctly located in the cytosol (GO:0005829), some of these locations lack evidence annotations. Consider adding evidence for all cellular locations.

Technical Correctness

The model follows GO-CAM best practices for representing enzymatic activities and causal relationships. The use of molecular functions, cellular components, and biological processes is consistent with GO-CAM modeling guidelines.

Biological Validation

The model accurately represents the pathway of glycogen breakdown: 1. Phosphorylase kinase (Phkg1) activates glycogen phosphorylase (Pygb) 2. Glycogen phosphorylase breaks down glycogen by releasing glucose-1-phosphate 3. The debranching enzyme (Agl) with its dual activities helps process the branched portions of glycogen 4. Phosphoglucomutases (Pgm1, Pgm2) convert glucose-1-phosphate to glucose-6-phosphate

This matches established knowledge of glycogen metabolism.

Recommendations

  1. Consolidate the duplicate Pygb activities into a single node to improve clarity.
  2. Add evidence for causal relationships between activities.
  3. Ensure consistent use of specific biological process terms throughout the model.
  4. Add evidence for all cellular location associations.

Overall, this is a well-constructed GO-CAM model that effectively represents the process of glycogen catabolism in mouse. With the suggested minor improvements, it would be an excellent reference model for the glycogen catabolic pathway.