Skip to content

663d668500001911 purine nucleobase metabolic process GO 0006144

Based on the information obtained, I can now provide a comprehensive review of the GO-CAM model.

GO-CAM Model Review for gomodel:663d668500001911

Overview

This GO-CAM model titled "purine nucleobase metabolic process (GO:0006144)" represents the purine nucleotide biosynthesis and salvage pathways in Schizosaccharomyces pombe (fission yeast). It comprehensively captures both de novo biosynthetic pathways and salvage pathways for purines (adenine and guanine).

Strengths

  1. Comprehensive Pathway Coverage:
  2. The model successfully represents both de novo purine biosynthesis and salvage pathways
  3. Includes transport mechanisms for purine bases across the plasma membrane

  4. Captures conversion pathways between different purine nucleotides (IMP → AMP, IMP → GMP)

  5. Well-Evidenced Assertions:

  6. Most activities have appropriate experimental evidence codes (ECO:0000314 - direct assay evidence)
  7. Key activities are supported by published literature with PMID references

  8. Uses appropriate evidence codes for different types of assertions (direct assay, sequence similarity, etc.)

  9. Proper Molecular Function Annotations:

  10. Enzymes are annotated with specific molecular functions matching their biochemical roles

  11. The appropriate contexts for each activity are provided (part_of relationships)

  12. Appropriate Causal Connections:

  13. The model uses the appropriate causal relation "provides input for" (RO:0002413) to connect activities in a metabolic pathway

  14. The flow of activities follows the established biochemical pathway for purine metabolism

  15. Input/Output Annotations:

  16. Many activities have appropriate input/output molecules specified
  17. Key metabolites like IMP (CHEBI:17202) and guanine (CHEBI:16235) are properly referenced

Areas for Improvement

  1. Evidence Documentation:
  2. One causal association from activity 663d668500001911/663d668500002065 to 663d668500001911/663d668500002073 lacks evidence annotations

  3. Some has_input/has_output annotations could be more consistently applied across related activities

  4. Molecular Details:

  5. The model could benefit from more systematic annotation of all inputs and outputs for each activity

  6. Additional molecular details for some transport processes would enhance the model

  7. Completeness Check:

  8. It would be useful to verify if the model captures all known enzymes involved in purine metabolism in S. pombe
  9. Potential regulatory interactions (if known) are not captured in the current model

Biological Accuracy

Based on the available information, the model appears to be biologically accurate and consistent with what is known about purine metabolism in yeast. The model includes key enzymes such as:

  • IMP dehydrogenase (gua1, SPBC2F12.14c) for GMP biosynthesis
  • Phosphoribosylaminoimidazolecarboxamide formyltransferase (ade10, SPCPB16A4.03c)
  • Adenylosuccinate synthase (ade2, SPAC144.03)
  • Transport proteins for adenine and guanine

The causal flow and pathway organization match established biochemical knowledge of purine metabolism.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model "gomodel:663d668500001911" is a high-quality representation of purine nucleobase metabolic processes in S. pombe. It effectively captures the key activities, causal relationships, and molecular participants in this pathway.

The model follows GO-CAM best practices for representing metabolic pathways, with appropriate molecular functions, biological processes, and causal connections. The model creator has made good use of available evidence codes and literature references to support the assertions.

With minor improvements to evidence documentation and molecular details, this would be an exemplary GO-CAM model. Overall, I recommend this model for approval with only minor revisions to address the missing evidence for one causal association and to ensure consistent annotation of inputs/outputs across all activities.