Skip to content

665912ed00000652 pericentric heterochromatin formation GO 0031508

Now, let me review the model based on GO-CAM best practices and biological accuracy. First, I'll check for any relevant GO-CAM guidelines that might apply to this model.

This is a detailed model representing pericentric heterochromatin formation (GO:0031508) in Schizosaccharomyces pombe (fission yeast). I'll structure my review to cover several key aspects of the model.

Model Overview

This GO-CAM model (https://bioregistry.io/go.model:665912ed00000652) represents the molecular mechanisms involved in pericentric heterochromatin formation in fission yeast. The model includes multiple interconnected pathways involving:

  1. RNAi-mediated heterochromatin formation (siRNA pathway)
  2. Histone modification activities (methylation, deacetylation)
  3. Heterochromatin protein complexes (CLRC, SHREC, RITS, etc.)
  4. RNA processing machineries

Structural Assessment

Connectivity and Flow

  • The model shows good connectivity between activities with appropriate causal predicates (RO:0002413 "provides input for", RO:0002629 "directly positively regulates", etc.)
  • The flow follows the biological sequence from RNA processing to chromatin modification to heterochromatin formation

Completeness

  • The model comprehensively captures key proteins known to be involved in S. pombe heterochromatin formation
  • Multiple complexes are represented with their components and functions (CLRC, SHREC, RITS, ARC, RDRC)
  • Both enzymatic activities (methyltransferase, deacetylase) and binding activities are represented

Biological Accuracy

The model accurately represents the current understanding of pericentric heterochromatin formation in S. pombe:

  1. RNAi Machinery: The model includes Dcr1 (Dicer), Ago1 (Argonaute), and the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase Rdp1, which are essential components of the RNAi pathway that initiates heterochromatin formation.

  2. Histone Modifications: The model correctly shows Clr4 as the H3K9 methyltransferase and includes deacetylases (Clr3, Sir2) that remove acetyl groups from histones to facilitate heterochromatin formation.

  3. Heterochromatin Proteins: The model includes HP1 homologs (Swi6, Chp2) that bind methylated H3K9 and contribute to heterochromatin spreading and maintenance.

  4. Adaptor Proteins: The inclusion of Stc1 as an adaptor between RNAi and chromatin modification machinery is biologically accurate.

Evidence and Attribution

  • All activities have appropriate evidence codes with PMID references
  • Evidence types include experimental evidence (ECO:0000269), direct assay (ECO:0000314), and mutant phenotype (ECO:0000315)
  • The model has consistent attribution with ORCID identifiers

Recommendations for Improvement

While the model is of high quality, I have a few minor suggestions:

  1. Unknown Molecular Functions: Several activities (e.g., gomodel:665912ed00000652/665912ed00000704, gomodel:665912ed00000652/665912ed00000722) have "GO:0003674" (molecular function) as their function, indicating unknown molecular function. It would be beneficial to update these with more specific functions when the literature supports it.

  2. Missing Evidence: A few causal associations lack evidence codes, such as the causal association between Clr1 and Clr3 activities. These should be added if available in the literature.

  3. Pathway Organization: The model could potentially benefit from more explicit organization into sub-pathways (e.g., RNAi pathway, histone modification pathway) to improve readability, though this is a minor point as the connections are already clear.

Conclusion

This GO-CAM model (https://bioregistry.io/go.model:665912ed00000652) is a high-quality representation of pericentric heterochromatin formation in S. pombe. It accurately captures the biological processes and molecular functions involved, with appropriate evidence and attribution. The model follows GO-CAM best practices in terms of connectivity, biological accuracy, and evidence standards.

The model effectively represents the current understanding of how RNAi machinery, histone modifiers, and heterochromatin proteins coordinate to establish and maintain pericentric heterochromatin in fission yeast. It would serve as an excellent example for similar pathway modeling efforts.