Skip to content

Based on my review of the GO-CAM model and associated documentation, I'll now provide a comprehensive review of the GO-CAM model gomodel:665912ed00002626 for nitrogen cycle metabolic process.

Review of GO-CAM Model: gomodel:665912ed00002626

Overview

This model represents the nitrogen cycle metabolic process (GO:0071941) in Schizosaccharomyces pombe (NCBITaxon:4896), focusing on urea metabolism and the urea cycle. The model includes multiple molecular functions and causal relationships that form the pathway of nitrogen metabolism.

Strengths

  1. Comprehensive pathway representation: The model effectively captures the urea cycle and related nitrogen metabolism pathways, representing the relationships between different enzyme activities and metabolites.

  2. Evidence-based assertions: Most activities have appropriate evidence codes and references to scientific literature, such as PMID:24177583 and PMID:1313366 which provide experimental evidence for the described activities.

  3. Proper use of causal relationships: The model correctly uses the "provides input for" relationship (RO:0002413) to connect sequential enzymatic activities in the pathway.

  4. Detailed molecular context: The model includes inputs and outputs for many activities, using appropriate CHEBI identifiers for metabolites.

Issues and Recommendations

  1. Incomplete evidence for some causal relationships: Several causal associations lack evidence codes, including:
  2. The causal relationship between gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002652 and gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002676
  3. The causal relationship between gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002652 and gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002668
  4. The causal relationship between gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002657 and gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002676

Recommendation: Add appropriate evidence codes with references to these causal relationships to strengthen the model's validity.

  1. CHEBI-enabled activity issue: In activity gomodel:665912ed00002626/66e382fb00001783, a chemical entity (CHEBI:36080 - protein) is listed as enabling the activity instead of a gene product.

Recommendation: Replace this with the appropriate gene product if the specific gene is known, or consider another annotation approach if this represents a protein with unknown identity.

  1. Missing evidence for molecular function: The activity gomodel:665912ed00002626/66e382fb00001783 lacks evidence for its molecular function (GO:0004038 - allantoinase activity).

Recommendation: Add appropriate evidence code and reference for this activity.

  1. Missing inputs/outputs: Some activities lack explicit inputs or outputs:
  2. Activity gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002645 (argininosuccinate synthase activity) doesn't specify its inputs/outputs

Recommendation: Add the relevant metabolites as inputs and outputs for these activities to provide a more complete biochemical representation.

  1. Multiple identical causal edges: There are duplicate causal relationships between the same activities:
  2. Two identical edges from gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002676 to gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002637

Recommendation: Remove redundant edges to keep the model clean and consistent.

  1. Metabolite redundancy: Some activities list the same output molecule twice:
  2. Activity gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002668 has CHEBI:16199 (urea) listed twice as output
  3. Activity gomodel:665912ed00002626/665912ed00002698 has CHEBI:28938 (ammonium) listed twice as output

Recommendation: Remove duplicate metabolite entries to avoid redundancy.

  1. Consistency of activity representation: The model transitions between representing a pathway via sequential activities and via a more direct process, which can be confusing. For example, some parts show detailed step-by-step enzymatic reactions while others have more direct connections.

Recommendation: Maintain a consistent level of granularity throughout the model where possible, or clearly delineate different subpathways.

Biological Content Validation

The biological content of the model is largely consistent with the literature regarding urea cycle and nitrogen metabolism in S. pombe. The key paper PMID:24177583 by Kinghorn and Fluri (1984) confirms the roles of uricase, allantoinase, allantoicase, and urease activities in the purine degradation pathway leading to nitrogen release.

The model correctly represents these enzymes and their relationships. For example, the paper describes the ure1, ure2, ure3, and ure4 genes as encoding components of urease, which is consistent with the model's representation of urease activity.

The model is also consistent with the arginine metabolism described in PMID:1313366, which details ornithine carbamoyltransferase in the arginine biosynthetic pathway in S. pombe.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model for nitrogen cycle metabolic process (gomodel:665912ed00002626) is a well-constructed representation of urea metabolism and the urea cycle in S. pombe. It effectively represents the biological knowledge from the literature and mostly follows GO-CAM best practices.

The model would benefit from the addition of missing evidence codes, removal of redundancies, and more consistent representation of inputs and outputs. Additionally, clarifying the role of the CHEBI-enabled activity would improve the model's clarity and adherence to GO-CAM standards.

Overall, this model provides valuable information about nitrogen metabolism in S. pombe and, with the suggested improvements, would serve as an excellent resource for the research community.