Skip to content

Based on my comprehensive review of the GO-CAM model and related literature, I will now provide a detailed assessment of the model:

GO-CAM Model Review: gomodel:67086be200001578

Model Overview

This model, titled "Negative regulation of BNIP3 and BNIP3L via PPTC7 and FBXL4 (Human)", represents a biological pathway that negatively regulates mitophagy through the controlled degradation of the mitophagy receptors BNIP3 and BNIP3L/NIX via the PPTC7-FBXL4-RBX1 axis.

Scientific Content Assessment

The model accurately represents a recently discovered mechanism described in PMID:38992176, where PPTC7 acts as a molecular adaptor between the mitophagy receptors BNIP3/NIX and the SCFFBXL4 E3 ubiquitin ligase complex to facilitate the ubiquitination and subsequent degradation of these receptors, thereby suppressing mitophagy.

The key molecular interactions represented in the model are: 1. PPTC7 (Q8NI37) functioning as a protein-macromolecule adaptor (GO:0030674) 2. FBXL4 (Q9UKA2) serving as a ubiquitin ligase-substrate adaptor (GO:1990756) 3. RBX1 (P62877) acting as an E3 ubiquitin protein ligase (GO:0061630) 4. BNIP3 (Q12983) functioning as a mitochondrion autophagosome adaptor (GO:0140580)

All of these activities are correctly located at the mitochondrial outer membrane (GO:0005741), consistent with the published literature.

Model Structure and Connections

The model correctly depicts the flow of activities using appropriate causal connections: 1. PPTC7's adaptor activity provides input for (RO:0002413) FBXL4's adaptor activity 2. FBXL4's adaptor activity provides input for (RO:0002413) RBX1's ubiquitin ligase activity 3. RBX1's ubiquitin ligase activity directly negatively regulates (RO:0002630) BNIP3's mitophagy receptor activity

This structure accurately reflects the mechanism where PPTC7 facilitates the recognition of BNIP3/NIX by FBXL4, leading to their ubiquitination by the SCF complex and subsequent degradation, thereby inhibiting mitophagy.

Evidence Assessment

The model appropriately cites the primary research article (PMID:38992176) for most of the assertions, using the correct evidence code ECO:0000314 (direct assay evidence used in manual assertion). A secondary citation (PMID:22505714) supports BNIP3's role in mitophagy with appropriate evidence code ECO:0000315 (mutant phenotype evidence).

Conformance to GO-CAM Best Practices

The model follows GO-CAM best practices for representing molecular adaptors and E3 ubiquitin ligase complexes:

  1. Molecular Adaptor Representation: PPTC7 is correctly annotated with "protein-macromolecule adaptor activity" (GO:0030674), which aligns with the guidelines in the "Molecular_adaptor_activity" document.

  2. E3 Ubiquitin Ligase Representation: The model correctly depicts the SCF complex components:

  3. FBXL4 as the substrate adaptor with "ubiquitin ligase-substrate adaptor activity" (GO:1990756)
  4. RBX1 with "ubiquitin protein ligase activity" (GO:0061630)

This follows the pattern described in the "E3_ubiquitin_ligases" document for "When only substrate adaptor and substrate are known."

  1. Part_of Relationships: All activities are appropriately indicated as being "part_of" the biological process "negative regulation of mitophagy" (GO:1901525).

  2. Occurs_in Relationships: The cellular location is correctly specified for each activity, with PPTC7, FBXL4, and BNIP3 activities occurring in the mitochondrial outer membrane (GO:0005741) and RBX1's activity in the cytoplasm (GO:0005737).

  3. Causal Relationships: The model uses appropriate causal relationships between activities:

  4. "provides input for" (RO:0002413) between adaptor activities
  5. "directly negatively regulates" (RO:0002630) for the effect on BNIP3/NIX

Suggested Improvements

While the model is largely accurate and follows GO-CAM best practices, there are a few potential improvements:

  1. Missing Component: The model doesn't explicitly include other components of the SCF complex such as SKP1 and CUL1. According to the E3 ubiquitin ligases guidelines, these could be included for a more complete representation.

  2. BNIP3L/NIX Representation: Although the model title mentions both BNIP3 and BNIP3L/NIX, only BNIP3 is explicitly represented in the model. Since both proteins are regulated in the same manner according to PMID:38992176, BNIP3L/NIX (UniProtKB:O60238) could be added with the same relationships and activities.

  3. Additional Evidence: While most assertions have appropriate evidence, there is a second causal association between RBX1 and BNIP3 that lacks evidence codes. This should be remedied by adding the appropriate evidence codes and references.

Biological Accuracy

The model faithfully represents the current understanding of this pathway as described in the primary literature. The discovery that PPTC7 acts as an adaptor between BNIP3/NIX and the SCFFBXL4 E3 ubiquitin ligase complex is a recent finding (PMID:38992176) and the model accurately captures this mechanism.

The model correctly indicates that this process occurs at the mitochondrial outer membrane and ultimately leads to the negative regulation of mitophagy, which aligns with the biological understanding presented in the literature.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model "Negative regulation of BNIP3 and BNIP3L via PPTC7 and FBXL4 (Human)" is a high-quality representation of the recently discovered pathway regulating mitophagy. It follows GO-CAM best practices and accurately represents the biological mechanism with appropriate evidence.

The suggested improvements would enhance the model's completeness but do not detract from its current accuracy. The model provides a valuable contribution to our understanding of mitophagy regulation and would be useful for researchers in this field.