Skip to content

67086be200002592 Retinoid Metabolic Process 3 Mouse

Based on my review of the model and the available guidelines, I'll now provide a comprehensive review of GO-CAM model gomodel:67086be200002592.

GO-CAM Model Review: "Retinoid Metabolic Process 3 (Mouse)"

Model Overview

This model represents retinoid metabolic processes in mouse, including various enzymatic activities and molecular functions involved in processing and transporting retinoids. The model includes 8 activities centered around the retinoid metabolic process (GO:0001523).

Strengths

  1. Appropriate biological process annotation: All activities are correctly annotated as "part of" retinoid metabolic process (GO:0001523).
  2. Evidence support: Each activity has appropriate evidence codes with PMID references.
  3. Causal connections: The model appropriately uses RO:0002413 (provides input for) and RO:0002629 (directly positively regulates) to connect related activities.
  4. Cellular components: Appropriate cellular locations are specified for most activities.
  5. Use of molecular carrier activity: Rbp2 (MGI:MGI:97877) is correctly annotated with molecular carrier activity (GO:0140104) following the guidelines.

Issues and Recommendations

  1. Missing members in protein complex:
  2. The chylomicron (GO:0042627) protein complex is annotated without any members. According to the complex annotation guidelines, either specific proteins should be included or a GO complex term should be used when the specific subunits are not known.

  3. Recommendation: Add the specific protein members of the chylomicron complex if they are known.

  4. Incomplete input/output annotations:

  5. Some activities are missing has_input/has_output annotations, making it difficult to track the flow of molecules through the pathway.

  6. Recommendation: Add appropriate input/output annotations for each activity to fully specify the molecular conversions.

  7. Cellular component annotations:

  8. Activity gomodel:67086be200002592/67086be200002630 (Clps) is missing a cellular component annotation.

  9. Recommendation: Add the appropriate cellular location for this activity.

  10. Activity flow considerations:

  11. While the model shows Rbp2 (molecular carrier) providing input for Lrat (phosphatidylcholine-retinol O-acyltransferase activity), additional connections between other activities could enhance the model's clarity.

  12. Recommendation: Consider adding more causal connections between activities to better represent the complete pathway.

  13. Complex model readability:

  14. The model includes many proteins and activities but could benefit from clearer grouping or organization.

  15. Recommendation: Consider organizing related activities in a more structured manner to improve readability.

  16. Validation of enzymatic reactions:

  17. Some enzymatic reactions like retinyl-palmitate esterase activity (GO:0050253) could benefit from additional literature validation.
  18. Recommendation: Additional evidence references for key enzymatic steps would strengthen the model.

Conclusion

The GO-CAM model "Retinoid Metabolic Process 3 (Mouse)" is generally well-constructed and follows GO-CAM best practices. It effectively represents the flow of retinoid metabolism from molecular carrier activities through various enzymatic processes. With the minor improvements suggested above, particularly regarding the protein complex membership and complete input/output annotations, this model would provide an even clearer representation of retinoid metabolism.

The model successfully captures the key players in retinoid metabolism and uses appropriate causal connections to show the relationships between different activities. It effectively demonstrates how GO-CAM can be used to model complex metabolic pathways.