Skip to content

Based on my review of the GO-CAM model for MGI_MGI_109482 and the relevant guidelines and related information, I'll now provide a detailed review of the model.

GO-CAM Model Review: Cacna1a (MGI:MGI:109482)

Summary

This GO-CAM model (gomodel:MGI_MGI_109482) represents the mouse Cacna1a gene, which encodes a voltage-dependent P/Q-type calcium channel subunit alpha-1A. The model primarily documents the molecular activities of this calcium channel, its cellular locations, and some causal relationships with other proteins.

Model Overview

The model describes the Cacna1a protein's primary function as a voltage-gated calcium channel (GO:0005245) and high voltage-gated calcium channel (GO:0008331), occurring in various neuronal cell types. It also shows some causal relationships between Cacna1a and other proteins in signaling pathways.

Strengths

  1. Comprehensive molecular function annotation: The model appropriately captures the primary molecular function of Cacna1a as a voltage-gated calcium channel.
  2. Detailed cellular location information: The model includes annotations for cellular locations where Cacna1a functions, including specific neuron types like Purkinje cells (CL:0000121) and granule cells (CL:0000120).
  3. Evidence-based assertions: Each annotation is supported by literature evidence with appropriate ECO codes and PubMed references.
  4. Some causal relationships: The model includes some causal relationships showing how Cacna1a activity affects other proteins in signaling pathways.

Areas for Improvement

  1. Redundant annotations: There are many redundant annotations for the same molecular function (GO:0003674 - molecular_function) with different evidence codes. These should be consolidated to improve model clarity.

  2. Limited causal relationships: Given the importance of this calcium channel in various signaling pathways, the model would benefit from more detailed causal relationships showing how its activity connects to downstream processes.

  3. Pathway context: While the model shows some relationships with Penk (MGI:MGI:104629), Sst (MGI:MGI:98326), and Cck (MGI:MGI:88297), the broader biological pathway context could be more clearly defined.

  4. Complex representation: As a voltage-gated calcium channel, Cacna1a typically functions as part of a multi-subunit complex. According to the UniProt entry, "Voltage-dependent calcium channels are multisubunit complexes, consisting of alpha-1, alpha-2, beta and delta subunits in a 1:1:1:1 ratio." The model would benefit from representing these interactions according to the guidelines for representing complexes in GO-CAM.

  5. Molecular mechanism details: The model could include more details about how the channel functions mechanistically (e.g., voltage sensing, conformational changes) based on the UniProt information about the S4 segments functioning as voltage sensors.

  6. Biological process context: While there are some part_of relationships to biological processes, the model would benefit from more explicit connections to the various biological processes listed in UniProt (e.g., calcium ion transport, neurotransmitter release, etc.).

Specific Causal Relationship Review

The model includes three causal relationship instances:

  1. Cacna1a (GO:0008331) -[RO:0002305]→ Cck (GO:0048018)

  2. This represents a negative causal relationship where Cacna1a activity negatively affects Cck receptor ligand activity.

  3. Cacna1a (GO:0008331) -[RO:0002305]→ Sst (GO:0048018)

  4. This represents a negative causal relationship where Cacna1a activity negatively affects Sst receptor ligand activity.

  5. Cacna1a (GO:0008331) -[RO:0002305]→ Penk (GO:0048018)

  6. This represents a negative causal relationship where Cacna1a activity negatively affects Penk receptor ligand activity.

Additionally, there's a causal relationship with Cstl1 (GO:0008234) -[RO:0002629]→ Penk (GO:0048018), showing how Cstl1 peptidase activity directly positively regulates Penk activity.

These causal relationships use appropriate relation ontology terms but would benefit from more context and intermediate steps to better describe the complete signaling pathways.

Recommendations

  1. Consolidate redundant annotations: Remove duplicate GO:0003674 annotations and keep only the most specific molecular function terms with the strongest evidence.

  2. Enhance complex representation: Add representations of the other subunits of the calcium channel complex and their interactions with Cacna1a.

  3. Expand causal relationships: Add more detail to the existing causal relationships and include additional ones that reflect the diverse roles of this calcium channel in neuronal signaling.

  4. Add biological process context: Create more explicit connections to biological processes such as calcium ion transport, neurotransmitter release, and synaptic transmission.

  5. Include cellular component information: Add information about the localization of the channel to specific neuronal structures such as synapses and dendrites as mentioned in UniProt.

  6. Review pathway completeness: Ensure that the signaling pathways involving Penk, Sst, and Cck are completely represented with all intermediate steps.

Conclusion

The current GO-CAM model for Cacna1a provides a solid foundation but would benefit from additional details about its molecular interactions, complex formation, and role in broader biological processes. By addressing the recommendations above, the model would provide a more comprehensive and informative representation of Cacna1a's functions and would better follow GO-CAM best practices.